Pizza Supreme

" I visited Pizza Supreme after a friend recommended it. The atmosphere was pretty chill, a nice place to hang out with friends. I ordered their chicken parmesan hero and was pleasantly surprised—it was delicious and full of flavor! My only complaint would be how busy it was, which led to a bit of a longer wait time. But overall, it was a great experience, and I believe I'll be a regular customer from now on. " (*Curated Review*)

×

" Had a somewhat mixed experience during my visit. The pizza, which I ordered for takeout, was satisfactory at best. I feel like I was expecting more based on the raving reviews. While the crust was decent, it wasn't anything special. The service could have been warmer too. The staff seemed preoccupied, which left me feeling like just another customer. I think I might give them one more chance based on all the good things I've heard, but I hope to see some improvements next time! " (*Curated Review*)

×

" Being a pizza lover, I was keen to try Pizza Supreme, and it truly exceeded my expectations. The pizza was fresh and had a delightful crust. I went on a busy Saturday night and although the wait was slightly longer than anticipated, it was absolutely worth it. The atmosphere was bustling—people chatting and enjoying their meals, which contributed to the great vibe. I’ll be back for sure, as this is a hidden gem in the area! " (*Curated Review*)

×

" Absolutely one of the best pizza spots in New York! I was visiting the area and had to pop in after all the good things I heard. They did not disappoint! The service was fast, even with the busy environment. I ordered a Sicilian pie along with an antipasto salad, and both were amazing. The pizza was huge and had so much flavor. Their homemade dressing on the salad was delightful, making it one of the best meals I've had on this trip. I'll be back for sure! " (*Curated Review*)

×

" I had high hopes for Pizza Supreme after hearing so much buzz, but I must say I was let down. I ordered a pepperoni pizza, and it was super greasy. I understand that some people enjoy that, but it made the pizza difficult to eat. The flavor was okay, but nothing to rave about. The interiors were quite ordinary and not as inviting as I imagined, and then there was a lengthy wait despite placing the order ahead of time. It’s a bummer because I wanted to enjoy my meal more than I did. " (*Curated Review*)

×

" I’m not usually one to leave reviews, but I felt compelled after my visit. The food was incredible! I had a chicken parm sandwich that literally melted in my mouth. The bread was fresh, the chicken was juicy, and the sauce was flavorful without overpowering the other ingredients. Everything tasted fresh and homemade, which isn’t something you find in many pizza places these days! The only downside was the time it took to get my order—it was a busy day, and the place was packed. " (*Curated Review*)

×

" This place is an absolute treasure! The pizza is unlike any I've tasted outside of NYC. The crust is just right, with a perfect balance of sauce and cheese. The garlic knots are also a must-try. I've been recommending Pizza Supreme to all my friends. I can't say enough about how great the staff is; they're always welcoming and helpful. I'll definitely be back soon! " (*Curated Review*)

×