Nicolino's Restaurant
Italian Restaurant
$$
4.5
(705)
Nicolino's Restaurant is praised for its authentic Italian cuisine, characterized by flavorful dishes that resonate well with patrons looking for traditional tastes. The attentive service and warm atmosphere enhance the dining experience, making it a favored spot among locals. Many customers appreciate both the quality of food and the welcoming environment, often expressing a desire to return.
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (518) 842-4907
Address: 4515 NY-30, Amsterdam, NY 12010, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" While I had high expectations from Nicolino's based on previous reviews, my experience left a bit to be desired. The ambiance is charming; however, the service we received was lacking. It took a while to receive our drinks, and the food followed suit. On a positive note, I found the bread to be exceptional—freshly baked and warm! When the food finally arrived, the flavors were great, but the portion sizes did not seem as large as anticipated given the price. Overall, a decent Italian meal, though the service recovery needs attention. " (*Curated Review*)
" Nicolino's provided an unforgettable dining experience for us! We walked in on a busy Saturday night but were greeted with a warm smile and quickly seated. The menu offered a diverse selection of authentic Italian dishes, which made it hard to choose! We eventually settled on the lasagna and a seafood risotto. Both were out of this world! What made the meal even better was how large the portions were—definitely worth the price! The atmosphere was vibrant and lively, making it a fun place to celebrate with friends. We can't wait to return! " (*Curated Review*)
" Visited Nicolino's for a family dinner and had a wonderful time. The southern Italian flavors were present in every bite of my spaghetti with meatballs, which were very authentic and paired perfectly with the homemade marinara sauce. I appreciated the freshness of the ingredients as well as the hearty portions. What really stood out was how engaged the staff were. Our waitress made fantastic recommendations. Definitely would revisit! " (*Curated Review*)
" I thought I'd give Nicolino's a try based on rave reviews. I ordered the seafood risotto and found it rather bland, which was a little disappointing. The portion size was generous, and I appreciated that, but a seafood dish should pack more flavor, especially for its price point. The service, however, was very helpful when I expressed my dissatisfaction; they offered to let me try another dish at no extra charge. The restaurant atmosphere was lively and cozy, which I enjoyed, but the food left me feeling underwhelmed this time around. " (*Curated Review*)
" If you're looking for a place that encapsulates the essence of Italian dining, Nicolino's is it! My husband and I celebrated our anniversary here, and we couldn't have asked for a better meal. The service was promptly excellent as our waiter made us feel right at home. We started with the bruschetta, which was fresh and bursting with flavor. For the main course, I had the chicken piccata, and my husband enjoyed the veal marsala; both dishes were exquisite, showcasing the restaurant's authenticity. The portions were plenty, leaving us both satisfied without feeling stuffed. Highly recommend this charming restaurant for an authentic Italian experience! " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (566)
" We stopped in for lunch, and I had the chicken sorrentino, which was gluten-free and delicious! It's not often I find Italian cuisine prepared without gluten that tastes so authentic. The staff was friendly and very accommodating regarding my dietary restrictions. The only minor drawback was that the waiting time was somewhat longer than expected, but the quality of food made it worthwhile. The portion was generous, leaving me completely satisfied. I'll definitely be back for more! " (*Curated Review*)
" What an experience at Nicolino's! We celebrated our anniversary here, and every aspect of the meal made it special. The wait staff was attentive and helped create a lovely setting. The food came out quick. I had the shrimp fettucine and was pleasantly surprised by how fresh the shrimp tasted! Portions were more than ample. If you're in the area, you must stop here. We will definitely be back! " (*Curated Review*)
Have been to Nicolino's Restaurant? Share your experience with other people!
Explore Other Cuisines Near Amsterdam, New York 12010
Top rated nearby
Address: 24 N Main St, Broadalbin, NY 12026, USA
Address: 11 Woodrow Rd, Amsterdam, NY 12010, USA
Address: 4908 NY-30, Amsterdam, NY 12010, USA
Address: 54 Bridge St, Amsterdam, NY 12010, USA
Address: 119 Riverview Dr, Amsterdam, NY 12010, USA
Address: 4803 NY-30 #9, Amsterdam, NY 12010, USA
Address: 1 Port Jackson Square, Amsterdam, NY 12010, USA
Address: 2 N Main St, Broadalbin, NY 12025, USA
Address: 2 Van Derveer St, Amsterdam, NY 12010, USA
Address: 4879 NY-30 Unit 8, Amsterdam, NY 12010, USA