Casa Rustica

Italian Restaurant $$$ 4.2 (351)

Casa Rustica offers a warm and cozy atmosphere along with a selection of mostly authentic Italian dishes. Many customers have praised the freshness and quality of the food, particularly the seafood and pasta offerings. However, there have been some instances of inconsistent service, which could affect the overall dining experience.

Overall:

4.5

(292 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.4

Atmosphere:

4.1

Service:

3.9

Restaurant website: Website

Phone number: (631) 265-9265

Address: 175 W Main St, Smithtown, NY 11787, USA

Opening hours

Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 12:00 – 10:00 PM
Wednesday: 12:00 – 10:00 PM
Thursday: 12:00 – 10:00 PM
Friday: 12:00 – 10:00 PM
Saturday: 5:00 – 10:00 PM
Sunday: 2:00 – 9:00 PM

Photo gallery

Service options

  • Dine-In Available
  • Takeout Available
  • Curbside Pickup Available
  • Reservable

Offerings

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Beer
  • Wine
  • Cocktails
  • Dessert
  • Coffee

Amenities

  • Restroom Available

Good for

  • Good for Children
  • Good for Groups

Payment options

  • Credit Cards
  • Debit Cards
  • NFC Payments

Parking options

  • Free Parking Lot
  • Valet Parking

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair Accessible Parking
  • Wheelchair Accessible Entrance
  • Wheelchair Accessible Restroom
  • Wheelchair Accessible Seating

Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)

**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**

" Absolutely loved our dining experience! The freshness of the seafood and the quality of ingredients shone through in every dish we ordered. The service was friendly and prompt, making our meal that much better. Will definitely be returning for more! " (*Curated Review*)

1 year ago

" The portions were decent, but the flavors didn't excite me. It was good, but I've had better Italian elsewhere. The management seemed disinterested in feedback, which is a shame. Overall, it felt like a missed opportunity. " (*Curated Review*)

1 year ago

" Our visit to Casa Rustica was a rollercoaster. The food was excellent - I ordered the veal chop and it was delightfully tender. However, the service was quite slow and we had to wait a while to get our drinks refilled. Overall, I'd say it was a decent experience but could use some improvement. " (*Curated Review*)

1 year ago

" The service was quick, and the food was delicious. I especially loved the combination of flavors in the seafood pasta. I would recommend Casa Rustica for a meal with family or friends anytime! " (*Curated Review*)

9 months ago

" I visited Casa Rustica for a corporate luncheon, and I was very impressed! The staff did an excellent job accommodating our large group, and the food was hot and delicious. My favorite was the chicken parmigiana which was cooked to perfection. If you're considering a place for an event, I'd recommend this restaurant! " (*Curated Review*)

1 year ago

Archived Reviews (282)

" Very lovely place with a great atmosphere. The children were welcomed with open arms, which made our family gathering all the more enjoyable. The staff ensured we had everything we needed while we feasted on a delicious selection. Would recommend for family outings! " (*Curated Review*)

2 years ago

" I love Casa Rustica! The lobster and seafood dishes are simply the best. The atmosphere is inviting, and the staff is always friendly. I recommend this place to anyone looking for high-quality Italian food! " (*Curated Review*)

2 years ago
More reviews not shown...

Have been to Casa Rustica? Share your experience with other people!

Please enter at least 15 characters.
no selection

Explore Other Cuisines Near Smithtown, New York 11787

Top rated nearby

Prato 850
Italian Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.7

(603 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.5

Atmosphere:

4.6

Service:

4.7

Address: Mayfair Shopping Center, 204 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, NY 11725, USA
Meet Noodle
Ramen Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.8

(244 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.6

Atmosphere:

4.8

Service:

4.7

Address: 2166 Nesconset Hwy, Stony Brook, NY 11790, USA
The Trattoria
Italian Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.9

(251 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.8

Atmosphere:

4.7

Service:

4.9

Address: 532 N Country Rd, St James, NY 11780, USA
Am Express (Tacos cilantro el compaye)
Mexican Restaurant $$

Overall:

5.0

(34 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.8

Atmosphere:

4.7

Service:

4.9

Address: 243 N Country Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787, USA
Lâu Vietnamese pho：pho;vietnamese;asian;viet;food;phó;fans;noodle;soup;dish;cuisine;restaurant;grill;chicken/越南 河粉 餐厅 越南菜
Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.8

(193 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.6

Atmosphere:

4.7

Service:

4.8

Address: 556 N Country Rd #22, St James, NY 11780, USA
Sempre Vivolo
Italian Restaurant $$$

Overall:

4.8

(287 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.8

Atmosphere:

4.7

Service:

5.0

Address: 696 Motor Pkwy, Hauppauge, NY 11788, USA
Mezza Luna
Italian Restaurant

Overall:

4.7

(104 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.7

Atmosphere:

4.5

Service:

4.6

Address: 644 Vanderbilt Motor Pkwy, Hauppauge, NY 11788, USA
JBBQ Hot Pot & BBQ
Restaurant $$

Overall:

5.0

(697 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.8

Atmosphere:

5.0

Service:

5.0

Address: 41 NY-111, Smithtown, NY 11787, USA
Insignia Prime Steak & Sushi
Restaurant $$$$

Overall:

4.6

(1687 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.4

Atmosphere:

4.7

Service:

4.4

Address: 610 Smithtown Bypass, Smithtown, NY 11787, USA
Takumi Japanese Restaurant Commack
Japanese Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.7

(149 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.8

Atmosphere:

4.6

Service:

4.7

Address: 149 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Commack, NY 11725, USA