Original Italian Pizza
Pizza Restaurant
$
4.3
(805)
The restaurant offers a delightful dining experience with a strong focus on authentic Italian cuisine. Many customers have applauded the quality of the food, particularly the pizza and pasta dishes, while some have highlighted service inconsistencies at times.
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (570) 888-9167
Address: 205 S Keystone Ave, Sayre, PA 18840, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" I visited Original Italian Pizza last week after hearing great reviews, and I must say, it did not disappoint! The pizza was incredibly fresh with a crust that was just the right amount of crispy. The toppings were generous and full of flavor, especially the pepperoni which tasted like it came straight from Italy. The staff was friendly and accommodating, making my dining experience even better. I can't wait to return with my family! " (*Curated Review*)
" Tried this restaurant for the first time. The pizza was good but maybe not as good as I expected. The toppings were fresh but I found the crust a tad too thick for my liking. Service was decent, and the place was quite busy, which speaks to its popularity. The atmosphere has a nice vibe. I might come back to try the pasta dishes everyone echoes about. " (*Curated Review*)
" I have mixed feelings about my visit to Original Italian Pizza. I ordered the famous spaghetti with marinara sauce, which was decent but not as remarkable as I had expected. The sauce was a bit runny, lacking the robust flavor I crave in Italian cuisine. However, the garlic bread was phenomenal! The service was attentive and friendly, which is always a plus. I'll give it another shot, but I hope the pasta improves next time. " (*Curated Review*)
" The atmosphere at Original Italian Pizza is delightful, but unfortunately, my meal wasn't as impressive. The stuffed shells I ordered were average; they didn't have much flavor, and the accompanying marinara sauce was runny. On a positive note, the staff went above and beyond to ensure I was taken care of, which is greatly appreciated. I might give it another go but will try a different dish. " (*Curated Review*)
" I recently tried the cheesesteak and it was a mixed bag. While the bread was beautifully crusty and fresh, there seemed to be more bread than meat, which left me a bit disappointed. The flavor was good overall, but I expected more heft for the price. Staff were friendly and service was prompt. I might return, but I’d be cautious about what I order next time. " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (646)
" I had a lovely dining experience here yesterday. The calzone was delicious, stuffed to the brim with cheese and toppings that melted in my mouth. My dining companion enjoyed the chicken parmigiana, which was also quite tasty. The service was quick, and our server was friendly and engaging. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for a hearty meal! " (*Curated Review*)
" After seeing so many positive reviews, I had to try Original Italian Pizza. I ordered a Margherita pizza and it was okay. The cheese was tasty, but the basil was too much and came straight off the plant! I appreciate the freshness, but sometimes less is more. The ambiance was nice, perfect for a casual night out. Service was prompt and friendly, can’t complain there. Overall, a solid spot. " (*Curated Review*)
Have been to Original Italian Pizza? Share your experience with other people!
Explore Other Cuisines Near Sayre, Pennsylvania 18840
Top rated nearby
Address: 1318 Elmira St, Sayre, PA 18840, USA
Address: 462 N Keystone Ave, Sayre, PA 18840, USA
Address: 326 Broad St, Waverly, NY 14892, USA
Address: 400 N Main St, Athens, PA 18810, USA
Address: 1 Garfield St, Waverly, NY 14892, USA
Address: 235 Desmond St, Sayre, PA 18840, USA
Address: 202 Desmond St, Sayre, PA 18840, USA
Address: 1645 Elmira St, Sayre, PA 18840, USA
Address: 407 S Main St, Athens, PA 18810, USA
Address: 115 S Thomas Ave, Sayre, PA 18840, USA