The Pie
Pizza Restaurant
$$
4.4
(498)
The Pie is highly regarded for its cozy atmosphere and generous portions, particularly praised for its authentic Italian pizza. Many guests enjoy the warm, inviting decor and the quality of the food, with a number of them highlighting the freshness of ingredients and the skilled service.
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (631) 331-4646
Address: 216 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" The Pie has a wonderful ambiance that makes eating there a treat. The decor is charming and the seating is comfortable. I ordered a mushroom and sausage pizza that was rich and hearty—definitely a great choice! My only complaint was that it was a little too oily for my taste. The service was prompt and friendly, which added to the pleasant atmosphere. I would recommend this place to anyone looking for a cozy dinner spot! " (*Curated Review*)
" Having heard so much about The Pie, I finally decided to check it out. The atmosphere was casual yet warm. I ordered the loaded veggie pizza, and while it was tasty, I felt it could have been a bit more cheesy. My friend ordered a meat lover's pizza, and she loved it! The server we had was quite knowledgeable about the menu and recommended some excellent drinks to pair with our meal. I was happy with the service. I would definitely come here again to try different menu items. " (*Curated Review*)
" I was excited to try The Pie based on all the good reviews, but my experience was a bit mixed. The pizza we ordered had great flavor, but it lacked the thickness I usually prefer. While it was well-cooked, I felt the portion sizes were smaller than expected for the price. However, the service was fantastic—our server was really attentive and friendly, which made up for the minor disappointment with the pizza. Overall, I might give it another try on a future visit. " (*Curated Review*)
" My family and I decided to check out The Pie for dinner and were pleasantly surprised. The pizza was amazing—loaded with fresh ingredients and a crispy crust. Our server was friendly and very accommodating. One dish we had that stood out was the baked ziti; highly recommend it! The only downside was the cost, which felt a bit high, but the overall experience made it worth it. " (*Curated Review*)
" I had high expectations for The Pie, but my experience fell short. When we arrived, the wait for a table was longer than anticipated, and once we got seated, the server seemed overwhelmed. The pizza was enjoyable, but nothing remarkable. I’ve definitely had better. I appreciate the cozy atmosphere, but I don’t think I’ll be rushing back anytime soon. " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (400)
" We decided to try The Pie on a whim for pizza night! The ambiance was casual and welcoming. I loved the barbecue chicken pizza, it was packed with flavor! The service was friendly, but it did take a little long to get our food. Overall, it was a pleasant experience and we’ll likely return. " (*Curated Review*)
" My experience at The Pie was a delightful surprise! The outdoor seating area was very cozy, and our server provided excellent service. We ordered a variety of dishes, and while everything was generally good, the highlight was definitely the pizza—especially the pepperoni! The crust was perfectly done. Prices felt a little steep, but I’d return for the quality ingredients and attentive staff. " (*Curated Review*)
Have been to The Pie? Share your experience with other people!
Explore Other Cuisines Near Port Jefferson, New York 11777
Top rated nearby
Address: 749 Mount Sinai-Coram Rd, Mt Sinai, NY 11766, USA
Address: 556 N Country Rd #22, St James, NY 11780, USA
Address: 532 N Country Rd, St James, NY 11780, USA
Address: 5507 Nesconset Hwy Suite #16, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776, USA
Address: 111 W Broadway, Port Jefferson, NY 11777, USA
Address: 2166 Nesconset Hwy, Stony Brook, NY 11790, USA
Address: 89 College Plaza, Selden, NY 11784, USA
Address: 2055 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720, USA
Address: 257 Echo Ave, Sound Beach, NY 11789, USA
Address: 389 Independence Plaza, Selden, NY 11784, USA