New Brother's Pizza
Pizza Restaurant
$
4.5
(262)
New Brother's Pizza is celebrated for its authentic pizza and diverse menu that resonates with the tastes of classic Italian-American cuisine. Many customers appreciate the freshness of the ingredients and the authentic flavors that remind them of New York-style pizza. The service is generally regarded as friendly, though some have reported inconsistencies on busy days. Overall, it is a popular spot worth revisiting.
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (540) 949-8900
Address: 2006 Jefferson Hwy, Fishersville, VA 22939, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" The experience at New Brother's Pizza was nearly perfect. I ordered the margarita pizza and was blown away by how fresh and fragrant the basil was. It tasted like a slice right out of Italy! The service was prompt and attentive, and the restaurant has a cozy atmosphere that makes you want to linger a little longer. They also have this amazing garlic dipping sauce that paired wonderfully with the crust. I’ll be back to try more from their menu; I can’t get enough! " (*Curated Review*)
" New Brother's Pizza has always been my go-to for pizza in this area. The delivery is fast, and the food is reliably good. I usually get some combination of a large pizza and a side of wings, and they’re always delicious. Even when they’re busy, they make an effort to keep the quality high. I’m impressed with how they consistently deliver good food and service! " (*Curated Review*)
" I recently tried New Brother's Pizza after hearing many recommendations, and I was quite pleased! Their crust is perfectly baked, and the toppings were fresh and generous. Definitely worth the hype! I was really impressed with the customer service too—it felt personal and welcoming. I can see why this place has such loyal followers! " (*Curated Review*)
" Had a mixed experience at New Brother's Pizza lately. On one hand, the pizza is still incredibly tasty, and the flavors are on point, but on the other, our last order was missing some items. When I called to rectify the issue, the staff was friendly but seemed overwhelmed, and it took a while to get the missing items. It was frustrating, but I understand that they can get busy. I do plan to return; hopefully, the service will improve next time because the food is really good! " (*Curated Review*)
" A lovely little spot for a casual meal with friends. I ordered the veggie pizza, and it was deliciously fresh. I loved the combination of veggies they used; it was a hearty meal without feeling heavy. The portions were generous, and I enjoyed every bite. The ambiance was laid-back and welcoming, which made for a pleasant evening. I recommend this pizza place to anyone looking for good food and good vibes! " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (211)
" New Brother's Pizza has become a staple for our family pizza nights. We usually order multiple pizzas and wings, and everything is consistently delicious. I appreciate that they offer a good variety of toppings and their crust is always fresh. I’ve tried other pizza places nearby, but none compares to the flavor and texture here. Plus, their delivery is usually super fast, which is a major plus when you’re starving. Highly recommend trying the white pizza; it’s my personal favorite! " (*Curated Review*)
" New Brother's Pizza has become my favorite place for late-night cravings. Their garlic knots are to die for, and the pizza is always loaded with toppings. It's been a reliable source of good food whether I dine-in or get it delivered. The staff is usually quite friendly. However, on one occasion, I had a slight mix-up with my order, but the manager quickly corrected it, which I appreciated. Every experience has been mostly great, and I highly recommend this spot! " (*Curated Review*)
Have been to New Brother's Pizza? Share your experience with other people!
Explore Other Cuisines Near Fishersville, Virginia 22939
Top rated nearby
Address: 250 E Main St, Waynesboro, VA 22980, USA
Address: 2284 Jefferson Hwy STE 102, Fishersville, VA 22939, USA
Address: 2576 Stuarts Draft Hwy, Stuarts Draft, VA 24477, USA
Address: 2556 Jefferson Hwy, Waynesboro, VA 22980, USA
Address: 1027 Richmond Rd, Staunton, VA 24401, USA
Address: 32 Windward Dr, Fishersville, VA 22939, USA
Address: 109 Lew Dewitt Blvd C, Waynesboro, VA 22980, USA
Address: 401 N Poplar Ave C, Waynesboro, VA 22980, USA
Address: 2120 W Main St, Waynesboro, VA 22980, USA
Address: 325 E Main St, Waynesboro, VA 22980, USA