Onofrio's

Italian Restaurant $$ 4.6 (237)

Onofrio's is a treasured local Italian restaurant known for its authentic home-cooked dishes and warm atmosphere. Many customers appreciate the quality and taste of the food, including favorites like baked clams and chicken Parmesan. The service is frequently noted as friendly and accommodating, making it a welcoming place for families and parties alike.

Overall:

4.6

(201 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.5

Atmosphere:

4.3

Service:

4.6

Phone number: (631) 395-3332

Address: 421 Neighborhood Rd, Mastic Beach, NY 11951, USA

Opening hours

Monday: Closed
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: 4:00 – 9:30 PM
Thursday: 4:00 – 9:30 PM
Friday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM
Saturday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM
Sunday: 4:00 – 9:00 PM

Photo gallery

Service options

  • Dine-In Available
  • Takeout Available
  • Reservable

Offerings

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Beer
  • Wine
  • Cocktails
  • Dessert
  • Coffee

Amenities

  • Restroom Available

Good for

  • Good for Groups

Payment options

  • Credit Cards
  • Debit Cards
  • NFC Payments

Parking options

  • Free Parking Lot
  • Free Street Parking

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair Accessible Parking
  • Wheelchair Accessible Restroom

Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)

**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**

" Great hole-in-the-wall spot! The food is delicious and fresh! Our waiter was absolutely delightful and checked on us frequently. The eggplant parm was to die for! I will recommend Onofrio's to all my friends! " (*Curated Review*)

5 months ago

" Had the best family dinner here! We were celebrating an anniversary, and the staff treated us like royalty. The lobster ravioli was divine, and the dessert was simply the cherry on top. Can’t wait for my next visit! " (*Curated Review*)

5 months ago

" After reading so many positive reviews, I had high expectations. The pizza was good, but the service was a bit slow during peak hours. I think they need to hire more staff on weekends. Overall, a decent experience but not quite the best. " (*Curated Review*)

6 months ago

" Onofrio’s has been a part of the community for many years and it shows. The staff is always friendly, and the food tastes like it was made in your grandma’s kitchen. I love coming here for special occasions—it truly feels like home. " (*Curated Review*)

6 months ago

" This quaint place has become my new favorite since moving to the area. The pizza is superb, and the homemade marinara sauce is to die for! It's the perfect spot for a casual dinner or gathering. I love the local vibe, and the staff treats you like family. " (*Curated Review*)

10 months ago

Archived Reviews (191)

" This spot is alright, but I’ve had some better Italian elsewhere. The chicken Parmesan was on the dry side. Service was friendly enough, but I encountered a longer wait than expected. I might give it another shot since I've heard rave reviews about the pizza. " (*Curated Review*)

1 year ago

" Went for a family dinner and was blown away by the authenticity of the pasta dishes! The fettuccine Alfredo tasted just like my grandmother used to make. This is a must-visit place for anyone looking for real Italian food. " (*Curated Review*)

1 year ago
More reviews not shown...

Have been to Onofrio's? Share your experience with other people!

Please enter at least 15 characters.
no selection

Explore Other Cuisines Near Mastic Beach, New York 11951

Top rated nearby

Chicos Tex Mex Food Truck
Mexican Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.6

(46 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.7

Atmosphere:

4.5

Service:

4.4

Address: 160 Margin Dr W, Shirley, NY 11967, USA
Okeno Sushi
Japanese Restaurant $

Overall:

4.6

(479 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.5

Atmosphere:

3.8

Service:

4.1

Address: 451 Glen Dr, Shirley, NY 11967, USA
Alitalia
Pizza Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.6

(164 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.5

Atmosphere:

4.3

Service:

4.2

Address: 532 Montauk Hwy, Center Moriches, NY 11934, USA
Avino's Italian Table
Italian Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.6

(384 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.5

Atmosphere:

4.2

Service:

4.3

Address: 108 S Country Rd, Bellport, NY 11713, USA
Brothers Four Pizza
Pizza Restaurant $

Overall:

4.6

(251 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.5

Atmosphere:

4.5

Service:

4.4

Address: 310 Main St, Center Moriches, NY 11934, USA
Mama Lisa Restaurant
Italian Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.5

(1376 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.3

Atmosphere:

4.2

Service:

4.2

Address: 1226 Montauk Hwy, Mastic, NY 11950, USA
La Volpe Restaurant & Anton Pizzeria
Pizza Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.6

(648 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.4

Atmosphere:

4.5

Service:

4.4

Address: 611 Montauk Hwy, Center Moriches, NY 11934, USA
Cafe Castello
Italian Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.5

(168 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.5

Atmosphere:

4.2

Service:

4.4

Address: 141 S Country Rd, Bellport, NY 11713, USA
Bernie's Family Pizzeria
Pizza Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.6

(188 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.4

Atmosphere:

4.2

Service:

4.2

Address: 225 Montauk Hwy, Moriches, NY 11955, USA
El Sabor Del Pueblo
Restaurant $

Overall:

4.6

(362 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.5

Atmosphere:

4.3

Service:

4.4

Address: 430 Main St, Center Moriches, NY 11934, USA