Payne's Pizza & More
Pizza Restaurant
$
4.2
(886)
Payne's Pizza & More offers a casual dining experience with food that shows moments of authenticity, particularly in its pizza offerings. However, recent experiences have led to mixed reviews, with some customers expressing frustration over service inconsistencies and portion sizes. While overall ratings are moderate, many diners appreciate the effort in delivering quality pizza and other Italian-inspired dishes.
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (740) 389-4732
Address: 1624 Marion-Mt Gilead Rd, Marion, OH 43302, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" There is so much potential at Payne's, but they seem to be struggling lately. My last visit was not great—the first pizza I received was not what I ordered, and the second one took too long to be remade. However, when we finally got the right order, the pizza was delicious! I appreciate that they are trying to uphold their standards, but consistency is key, and I hope they can get there. The staff is nice, just seems overwhelmed at times. " (*Curated Review*)
" On my recent visit to Payne's, I ordered a stuffed pizza expecting something extraordinary but got the opposite instead. The stuffing was minimal and the crust didn’t live up to the expectations. On top of that, my order took longer than anticipated, and when it arrived, it was barely warm. I’m disappointed as I hear so many good things about this place. It's unfortunate because I do want to like it as the environment was pleasing and the staff seemed enthusiastic. " (*Curated Review*)
" Honestly, after our visit, my friends and I were left confused. One of us ordered pasta, which was mediocre, but the pizza was a hit! The atmosphere was cozy, and we loved how family-friendly it felt. Perhaps a mixed bag experience—considering some dishes really shine while others miss the mark. If we go again, I would just stick with the pizza and avoid the pasta. " (*Curated Review*)
" Payne's has a nice vibe and decent pizza. The toppings were fresh, but I was struck by how long it took to get our food even when the restaurant was not busy. I would return to give it another chance as the food itself was enjoyable. I hope that next time, they hit the mark on both service and food quality. " (*Curated Review*)
" I cannot express how much I loved the pizza at Payne's! It was crispy, cheesy, and just the right amount of sauce. Even as a vegetarian, I found their veggie pizza delightful, with fresh ingredients and generous toppings. The atmosphere was friendly and relaxed, perfect for family gatherings. I highly recommend trying their dessert pizzas as well; they were the perfect ending to a fantastic meal. Definitely one of my new favorite spots! " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (710)
" Every time I visit Payne's, the food is consistently good. Their garlic knots are a must-try! The pizza is well-prepared, and the toppings are fresh. The staff is usually friendly and loves to chat. The place can get crowded during peak hours, but I can't blame them, as it's becoming a favorite in the community! " (*Curated Review*)
" Payne's Pizza & More has some real potential. Their delivery is generally prompt, and the food is freshly prepared. I love their lasagna, but the last time I ordered, it seemed to be undercooked. However, their pizza always hits the spot. Excellent taste and freshly baked; it’s what keeps me coming back! Very keen to see what they’ll bring with the next order. " (*Curated Review*)
Have been to Payne's Pizza & More? Share your experience with other people!
Explore Other Cuisines Near Marion, Ohio 43302
Top rated nearby
Address: 160 McMahan Blvd, Marion, OH 43302, USA
Address: 1292 Delaware Ave, Marion, OH 43302, USA
Address: 669 N Main St, Marion, OH 43302, USA
Address: 1360 Mt Vernon Ave, Marion, OH 43302, USA
Address: 1713 Marion-Mt Gilead Rd Unit 113, Marion, OH 43302, USA
Address: 143 W Center St, Marion, OH 43302, USA
Address: 135 Edgefield Blvd, Marion, OH 43302, USA
Address: 1583 Marion-Waldo Rd, Marion, OH 43302, USA
Address: 1207 Mt Vernon Ave, Marion, OH 43302, USA
Address: 1834 Marion-Waldo Rd, Marion, OH 43302, USA