Nick & Toni's

Italian Restaurant $$$ 4.4 (321)

Nick & Toni's is celebrated for its inviting ambiance and commitment to authentic Italian cuisine. Customers frequently remark on the freshness of ingredients and the quality of dishes, such as the zucchini fries and seafood offerings, while service is praised for being attentive and friendly. However, fluctuations in food quality have been noted, particularly in recent visits, indicating that consistency may be an area for improvement.

Overall:

4.5

(268 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.2

Atmosphere:

4.4

Service:

4.0

Restaurant website: Website

Phone number: (631) 324-3550

Address: 136 N Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937, USA

Opening hours

Monday: 5:30 – 9:00 PM
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: 5:30 – 9:00 PM
Thursday: 5:30 – 9:00 PM
Friday: 5:30 – 10:00 PM
Saturday: 5:30 – 10:00 PM
Sunday: 5:30 – 9:00 PM

Photo gallery

Service options

  • Dine-In Available
  • Takeout Available
  • Reservable

Offerings

  • Dinner
  • Beer
  • Wine
  • Cocktails
  • Dessert
  • Coffee
  • Vegetarian Options Available

Amenities

  • Outdoor Seating
  • Restroom Available

Good for

  • Good for Groups

Payment options

  • Credit Cards
  • Debit Cards
  • NFC Payments

Parking options

  • Free Parking Lot
  • Free Street Parking

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair Accessible Parking
  • Wheelchair Accessible Entrance
  • Wheelchair Accessible Restroom
  • Wheelchair Accessible Seating

Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)

**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**

" After hearing great things about Nick & Toni's, I finally went, and it surpassed my expectations! The atmosphere was inviting and energetic, perfect for a fun night out. I had the lobster pasta, which was delightful, and their dessert selection is not to be missed. Will be back many times! " (*Curated Review*)

10 months ago

" Nick & Toni's remains a classic. The interior is stylish, but what I love most is the menu that changes with the seasons. The seafood is always fresh and expertly prepared. I highly recommend their signature dessert, Tartufo — it’s simply divine! Looking forward to our next visit! " (*Curated Review*)

11 months ago

" Overall, I enjoyed my experience at Nick & Toni's. The food was good but not groundbreaking, and the service was friendly yet a bit distracted. A great place for a casual meal with friends or family, just a touch on the pricier side for what you get. " (*Curated Review*)

11 months ago

" My recent meal at Nick & Toni's was delightful. The menu celebrates freshness and authenticity, especially with their Italian dishes. The service was helpful and friendly, although the wait for our food was longer than expected. Overall, it was an enjoyable experience, and we will return to explore more of the menu. " (*Curated Review*)

11 months ago

" We had a memorable dining experience at Nick & Toni's! The seating was cozy, giving us privacy while enjoying our meals. The pasta tasted authentic with rich flavors, and the staff ensured we were well taken care of throughout our stay. I would definitely recommend this place for a great night out! " (*Curated Review*)

1 year ago

Archived Reviews (258)

" I am always excited to try Nick & Toni’s with friends, and this visit did not disappoint! The service is consistently friendly, and the food never fails to impress. My favorite is the tiramisu, but I must say their pizza is an absolute must-try too. The ambiance makes you feel at home, a perfect place for gatherings. " (*Curated Review*)

1 year ago

" I appreciate the effort that goes into the dishes at this restaurant. The flavors, particularly in the risottos and fish entrees, really shine through. The dessert, a shared Tartufo, was enormous and wonderfully rich. If you're in the Hamptons, you shouldn't miss dining here! Just make sure to book ahead as it gets crowded. " (*Curated Review*)

1 year ago
More reviews not shown...

Have been to Nick & Toni's? Share your experience with other people!

Please enter at least 15 characters.
no selection

Explore Other Cuisines Near East Hampton, New York 11937

Top rated nearby

El Turco Hamptons
Turkish Restaurant

Overall:

4.7

(40 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.5

Atmosphere:

4.5

Service:

4.5

Address: 44 Three Mile Harbor Rd, East Hampton, NY 11937, USA
Sam's Restaurant
Italian Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.4

(212 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.4

Atmosphere:

4.1

Service:

3.9

Address: 36 Newtown Ln, East Hampton, NY 11937, USA
KUMISO
Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.5

(54 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.2

Atmosphere:

4.6

Service:

4.3

Address: Alley next to Breezin-Up, 37 Newtown Ln, East Hampton, NY 11937, USA
La Fondita
Mexican Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.3

(334 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.3

Atmosphere:

4.1

Service:

3.7

Address: 74 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY 11930, USA
Hampton Chutney Co.
Indian Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.5

(285 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.2

Atmosphere:

4.3

Service:

4.2

Address: 107 Newtown Ln, East Hampton, NY 11937, USA
Chen's Garden
Chinese Restaurant $

Overall:

4.7

(185 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.5

Atmosphere:

4.2

Service:

4.7

Address: 478 Pantigo Rd, East Hampton, NY 11937, USA
Serafina East Hampton
Italian Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.4

(186 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.3

Atmosphere:

4.4

Service:

3.8

Address: 104 N Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937, USA
Villa Italian Specialties
Italian Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.3

(187 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.3

Atmosphere:

4.1

Service:

3.8

Address: 7 Railroad Ave, East Hampton, NY 11937, USA
il Buco al Mare
Restaurant $$$

Overall:

4.5

(104 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.4

Atmosphere:

4.4

Service:

4.0

Address: 231 Main St, Amagansett, NY 11930, USA
Sí Sí Mediterranean Restaurant
Mediterranean Restaurant

Overall:

4.4

(235 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.2

Atmosphere:

4.6

Service:

3.9

Address: 295 Three Mile Harbor Hog Creek, East Hampton, NY 11937, USA