Goodfella's Pizzeria
Pizza Restaurant
$$
4.5
(179)
Goodfella's Pizzeria is highly praised for its consistency in serving high-quality, authentic pizza that resonates with traditional flavors. Customers repeatedly highlight the friendly and attentive service, contributing to a welcoming dining experience. This establishment appears to cater effectively to its patrons, ensuring they enjoy delicious food in a cozy atmosphere.
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (918) 782-2000
Address: 450677 OK-85, Afton, OK 74331, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" The staff are usually fantastic, but my last visit felt a bit off. The pizza was as good as ever, but the service was not up to their normal standards. I want to highlight their crust is absolute perfection! Hopefully, it was just a rough day because I truly enjoy eating here. I really hope to see things back to their usual level next time. " (*Curated Review*)
" Every since my first visit, I've been hooked! Goodfella's has the pizza style that feels nostalgic. The cheese bread is a must-try as well! Super flavorful and generous portions; it'll fill you up! The drive-thru is convenient, but I love dining in to soak in the atmosphere. Worth every penny! " (*Curated Review*)
" The gluten-free pizza here is fantastic! Living with dietary restrictions, it’s refreshing to find a place with such an incredible alternative. The staff's positivity while handling my many questions was commendable. I’ll make this a staple when in town with my family. The ambiance was pleasant; it felt homey rather than a cold corporate chain. I can’t wait to come back with friends to share this gem! " (*Curated Review*)
" Had an enjoyable meal at Goodfella's last weekend. I was in the mood for a good calzone, and they definitely delivered! Soft, filled to the brim with cheese and meats, it was divine. The staff made us feel like family. It's nice to see a local eatery thriving. The only downside was how busy it was, indicating just how popular this spot is. However, that only reinforces how great the food is. Would certainly come again! " (*Curated Review*)
" You really can't go wrong with Goodfella's Pizzeria. Their calzones are to die for, and the service feels bright and cheery. I often find myself craving it during lunch breaks! If you're looking for something authentic yet casual, look no further. Everyone behind the counter is knowledgeable, and they make sure you get what you need. My only issue is sometimes it gets a little too busy, which can lead to longer waits. " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (145)
" I just love Goodfella's Pizzeria! Their pizza is consistently amazing, and I particularly recommend the Meat Lovers for anyone looking for something hearty. The staff is always friendly, making you feel welcomed the moment you walk in. It’s also nice to see a small business supporting the local community. Each time I order, it’s ready just in time, and the portion sizes are generous. For a great pizza night, this is the place to go! " (*Curated Review*)
" As a pizza lover, I have high standards, and Goodfella's has exceeded them! Their toppings are fresh, and the crust is perfectly thin and crispy, which I prefer. I was particularly impressed with the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza; it is a must-try! The owner is passionate about his food, and it’s evident in every bite. While the drive-up location is convenient, I enjoyed dining in. This is my new go-to pizza place! " (*Curated Review*)