New York New York Pizza
Pizza Restaurant
$$
4.4
(584)
The restaurant serves a variety of pizzas and Italian dishes that are largely praised for their authenticity, which resonates well with customers from New York. Many reviews highlight the friendliness of the staff and the vibrant atmosphere, although there are occasional reports of inconsistency in food quality and service.
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (813) 926-6969
Address: 11203 Sheldon Rd, Tampa, FL 33626, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" They say you can't get good pizza in Florida, but New York New York Pizza proves that wrong! I enjoyed a delightful calzone that was perfectly stuffed with sausage, cheese, and pepperoni. Flaky on the outside and gooey on the inside, it hit the spot. Service was quick, and the staff was friendly as well. The only drawback was that their seating is limited, making it a bit cramped. I'd recommend getting your food to go. Overall, an excellent experience! " (*Curated Review*)
" My family and I visited New York New York Pizza last weekend after hearing a lot of hype. We were greeted warmly by the staff, which set a positive tone for our meal. We ordered a couple of pizzas and wings. The pizza was definitely good, with fresh ingredients and generous toppings. However, I felt it was slightly overcooked, which made the crust a bit tougher than I would have preferred. The wings were flavorful but could use a little more spice. Overall, we enjoyed our time there and would likely return to try different menu items! " (*Curated Review*)
" Each visit to New York New York Pizza gets better than the last! My family and I love the white pizza, generously topped with ricotta and spinach. The crust is baked to perfection and honestly rivals many places back in New York. It's such a pleasure to find this gem in Tampa! The atmosphere is family-friendly and cozy, although you're likely to find it busy during dinnertime. I can't recommend this spot enough! " (*Curated Review*)
" New York New York Pizza gets my vote for best NY-style pizza in Tampa! The crust is a standout; perfectly chewy without being overly doughy. I also loved the generous toppings on the supreme pizza, the sausage was perfectly seasoned. Service was quick, and the owner really knows how to treat his customers. I would recommend this to anyone who loves pizza and wants something authentic! " (*Curated Review*)
" I was really looking forward to dining at New York New York Pizza, but I must admit, it didn't quite meet my expectations. The pizza was decent but lacked the depth of flavor I've had elsewhere. I think the toppings were a bit scarce compared to other places I’ve been to. The service was alright, but there was a wait even for a small order. Not sure I’d risk a return visit. Hopefully, they can iron out some issues. " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (469)
" New York New York Pizza never fails to impress me! The buffalo chicken pizza is a must-try; it's so flavorful and the perfect amount of spicy! I also appreciate how generous they are with the toppings. The staff is consistently friendly and the atmosphere is warm and inviting. Just make sure to arrive early if you want a seat! My only complaint is positioning; they could use a bit more space for diners. Still, a fantastic choice for pizza lovers. " (*Curated Review*)
" Great find! Stumbled upon this pizza joint and happy I did. The atmosphere was lively and made for a great dinner experience with friends. The pizza was HUGE and delicious; the crust was thick and flavorsome while keeping a fine balance with the toppings. The staff worked hard, and you could see they were passionate about their pizza. Just be aware, the place can get packed! I'll definitely be coming back for another slice! " (*Curated Review*)
Have been to New York New York Pizza? Share your experience with other people!
Explore Other Cuisines Near Tampa, Florida 33626
Top rated nearby
Address: 3858 W Waters Ave, Tampa, FL 33614, USA
Address: 4134 W Boy Scout Blvd #1, Tampa, FL 33607, USA
Address: 5717 Gunn Hwy, Tampa, FL 33625, USA
Address: 5524 Van Dyke Rd, Lutz, FL 33558, USA
Address: 14306 N Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33618, USA
Address: 4349 W Waters Ave, Tampa, FL 33614, USA
Address: 14401 N Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33618, USA
Address: 2223 N Westshore Blvd #203, Tampa, FL 33607, USA
Address: 14351 N Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33618, USA
Address: 3617 W Humphrey St, Tampa, FL 33614, USA