Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery
Pizza Restaurant
$$
4.4
(298)
Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery is known for its authentic Italian cuisine and generous portion sizes. Many customers praise the quality of the food, especially the pizza and pasta dishes, citing freshness and homemade flavors. Despite occasional service hiccups, the overall dining experience is highly rated, making it a favorite for both casual takeout and family gatherings.
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (845) 561-6262
Address: 374 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor, NY 12553, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" A cozy place with classic Italian flavors. I had their lasagna which was beautifully layered with seasoned beef and robust marinara sauce. The flavors remind me of home-cooked meals. The service was prompt and friendly, adding to a pleasant dining experience. Can't wait to come back and try their special pizzas! " (*Curated Review*)
" I recently visited Mama Theresa's for the first time, and I was blown away! The ambiance is cozy and welcoming. I tried their famed fettuccini alfredo, and it did not disappoint—it was creamy and rich, just like you'd find in a trattoria in Italy. I also loved the complimentary garlic knots; they were soft and flavorful. Just a minor hiccup with service being a bit slow, but it was worth the wait for the delicious food. " (*Curated Review*)
" We ordered several pizzas for a family gathering, and everyone loved them! Each pizza was loaded with fresh toppings and had a great crust. This place is a staple in our lives now, and we look forward to our weekly pizza nights. " (*Curated Review*)
" The pizza was fantastic, but I noticed some inconsistencies in service. I've ordered delivery multiple times, and while most experiences have been great, I had one occasion where my order took way too long and wasn't quite right. However, the food is always worth it, the flavors are spot on, and portion sizes are generous! " (*Curated Review*)
" The stuffed shells are to die for! They taste like they were made in Grandma's kitchen. Cozy dining area with a neighborhood feel. I felt at home while dining which is truly makes a great dining experience. " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (240)
" We tried the catering service for a birthday party, and the feedback from guests was overwhelmingly positive! The pasta was al dente, the bread was fresh, and the staff handled the service efficiently. This place has become our go-to for events. Highly recommended! " (*Curated Review*)
" We decided to stop by after hearing about their famous garlic knots! I enjoyed a lovely pasta dish while my husband had their pizza. The garlic knots were as good as promised! This place really has a homey feel to it. Will return! " (*Curated Review*)
Have been to Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery? Share your experience with other people!
Explore Other Cuisines Near New Windsor, New York 12553
Top rated nearby
Address: 1008 Little Britain Rd, New Windsor, NY 12553, USA
Address: 815 Blooming Grove Turnpike, New Windsor, NY 12553, USA
Address: 118 Broadway, Newburgh, NY 12550, USA
Address: 135 Main St, Beacon, NY 12508, USA
Address: 374 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor, NY 12553, USA
Address: 40 Front St, Newburgh, NY 12550, USA
Address: 54 Quassaick Ave, New Windsor, NY 12553, USA
Address: 1795 NY-32, New Windsor, NY 12553, USA
Address: NY, 1004 NY-94, New Windsor, NY 12553, USA
Address: 238 Broadway, Newburgh, NY 12550, USA