Geno's Steakhouse
Steak House
$$
4.6
(560)
Geno's Steakhouse offers a delightful dining experience, known for its authentic Midwestern supper club vibe and fresh ingredients. Many customers praise the quality of the steaks and seafood, alongside a well-stocked salad bar. However, some have noted inconsistencies in service, particularly during busy hours, which may affect overall satisfaction.
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (920) 525-4029
Address: N8755 Old Hwy 47, Black Creek, WI 54106, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" I recently had dinner at Geno's and was pleasantly surprised! The ambiance is perfectly nostalgic of a Wisconsin supper club. I ordered the lobster tails, which were both succulent and well-prepared. The service was on point, even during peak dining hours. My only negative was the salad bar, which yes had good variations but could have included more unique offerings. Overall, I’d definitely recommend. " (*Curated Review*)
" Finally got to try Geno's Steakhouse, and I left feeling full and satisfied! The ambiance is exactly what one might expect from a classic Wisconsin supper club—warm, welcoming, and great for gathering with friends or family. I opted for the lobster-tail combo with my ribeye, and I really appreciated the freshness of the seafood. The staff was incredibly friendly, helping us select the perfect drinks to pair with our meal. A must-visit for anyone local or passing through! " (*Curated Review*)
" Geno's Steakhouse has a nice rustic feel; I felt like I stepped back in time! The wait for our table was worth it, as our meals were delicious. The steak I had was a bit salty, but the flavors were still exceptional, making up for it. The service was good initially but lost momentum toward the end when we needed refills. Overall, it’s a solid restaurant with some room for growth. Would come back to try more selections from the menu. " (*Curated Review*)
" Enjoyed a fabulous dinner at Geno's last night. The staff was incredibly attentive, and the ribeye was simply divine. The salad bar had all the usual favorites; however, they also offered some interesting choices that made it stand out. I felt the prices were very reasonable for the portion sizes. All in all, we had a wonderful experience and would happily recommend this place to others! " (*Curated Review*)
" Last weekend, I tried Geno's for the first time. I must say, the ambiance reminded me of traditional supper clubs from my childhood—comfortable and inviting. I opted for the tenderloin which, while tasty, was a little bit overcooked. The salad bar had a nice spread, yet I felt there could’ve been more unique items. Service was solid, if a bit slow due to a busy night. I enjoyed my overall experience but felt like there’s a little more potential for improvement. " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (450)
" Geno's wasn't bad, but it didn't meet the expectation set by others' reviews. While my steak was decent, it lacked that special flavor I've had at other places. The atmosphere was inviting, but the service could have been better organized. I felt a little neglected due to the busy nature of the restaurant. I would consider giving it another chance at a less busy time. " (*Curated Review*)
" An outstanding place for dinner! The steak was superb—tender and flavorful. We also enjoyed the variety on the salad bar, which was fresh and well-stocked. The service was friendly but a tad slow during peak hours; however, they were attentive and responsive. The ambiance was typically warm and inviting, just what one would expect from a supper club. Can't wait to return! " (*Curated Review*)