Marcello's Pizza
Pizza Restaurant
$
4.3
(548)
Marcello's Pizza brings a nostalgic pizza experience with a menu that has satisfied many customers. The authenticity of the food shines through, particularly their cheese pizza, which some customers rave about. While service receives high marks, it may occasionally be inconsistent, and there are mixed reviews regarding the cooking quality at different times.
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (717) 854-5454
Address: 7 S George St #1406, York, PA 17401, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" I’ve been coming to Marcello’s for over a decade, and the food remains consistently good. Their pizza has that perfect balance of toppings and sauce, just like a proper New York pizza should! The service staff really makes the experience pleasant. It is the kind of place where you can throw back some slices with friends after a long week. Highly recommend it! " (*Curated Review*)
" I must say that I was let down with my last visit. The pizza was okay, definitely not the best I’ve had, but acceptable. My chicken wings had a decent flavor but were a bit oily. Service was decent but could use more attentiveness. I'm not sure if I’d return given my last experience. " (*Curated Review*)
" I can’t stress enough how delicious the garlic sauce is at Marcello's! I usually opt for their garlic knots paired with the pizza, and it’s an unbeatable combination. I love how they maintain that classic pizzeria vibe, echoing the ones I visited in New York. The only drawback is the parking situation, but for such great food, it’s worth a little hassle. " (*Curated Review*)
" Always a treat to come here! They have their specials that change weekly. I tried the pasta special and was very impressed by how authentic the flavor was. The employees are helpful, and I never feel rushed, which is a huge plus. This will always be one of my favorite eateries in town. Highly recommended! " (*Curated Review*)
" Every time I visit change or improvement is apparent. The cleanliness of the restaurant is commendable. I appreciate how welcoming the staff is too. But food quality can be inconsistent; some dishes I’ve had were excellent while others have left something to be desired. I really enjoy their fries which are consistently good, though! " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (440)
" I’ve frequented Marcello’s for a while now, and I must point out their fantastic chicken salad. I was a bit disappointed when they switched mozzarella sticks, but thankfully they returned to the previous recipe that we loved. However, the last couple of times they’ve forgotten items in my order. Overall, I enjoy dining here, but I have to keep a closer eye on my takeout. " (*Curated Review*)
" This was one of my favorite pizza spots but sadly it doesn't have the same charm anymore. The pizza quality has slipped a bit - it often arrives lukewarm and lacks the kick it used to have. The staff is charming as always, yet I feel they could use extra help during busy hours. Homey atmosphere, but I’m worried about consistency in the food. " (*Curated Review*)
Have been to Marcello's Pizza? Share your experience with other people!
Explore Other Cuisines Near York, Pennsylvania 17401
Top rated nearby
Address: 1628 W Market St, York, PA 17404, USA
Address: 2444 Eastern Blvd, York, PA 17402, USA
Address: 24 S George St, York, PA 17401, USA
Address: 724 Loucks Rd, York, PA 17404, USA
Address: 887 E Market St, York, PA 17403, USA
Address: 34 W Philadelphia St, York, PA 17401, USA
Address: 26 N Main St, Jacobus, PA 17407, USA
Address: 101 S Duke St, York, PA 17401, USA
Address: 2180 York Crossing Dr, West Manchester Township, PA 17408, USA
Address: 330 Town Center Dr, York, PA 17408, USA