El Toro Cafe
Mexican Restaurant
4.3
(135)
El Toro Cafe, while cherished by some for its family-run atmosphere and long-standing presence in Newton, has received a significant amount of criticism regarding the authenticity of its Mexican cuisine. Many diners have noted a lack of traditional flavors, with several describing the food as bland and lacking the vibrant tastes commonly associated with genuine Mexican dishes. Despite some positive mentions of the service and ambiance, the overall impression leans towards disappointment in the quality of the food served.
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (316) 283-4044
Address: 121 W 5th St, Newton, KS 67114, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" After hearing mixed reviews, I finally gave El Toro Cafe a shot and was left somewhat underwhelmed. The food was serviceable but definitely missed the authentic mark I was hoping for. My tacos were drowned in cheese, overshadowing any potential flavor they could have had. The atmosphere is quaint enough, but that alone doesn't justify a visit if the food is just lukewarm at best. Service was cordial but not impressive. I might try another local Mexican place next time instead. " (*Curated Review*)
" Disappointed with our dining experience at El Toro Cafe. The ambiance was quite charming, but that was about the only thing that stood out positively. The food was unexciting; my tacos were bland and the salsa tasted more like ketchup. It felt like a poor version of what you’d get at a fast-food chain. The service was courteous but could have been more attentive. Despite its reputation, I won’t be returning. There are plenty of better options in town. " (*Curated Review*)
" El Toro Cafe is quaint, with a rustic charm that draws you in, but oh, the food is another story. The dishes I tried were strictly average at best. I was disappointed since I had been told this is a local favorite. The enchiladas were smothered in too much cheese, making them heavy and overly rich without enough flavor. I also noticed my beans didn't taste like they were seasoned at all. I wanted to enjoy my dinner, but it just fell flat. The only reason I may consider returning is to give it one last chance. " (*Curated Review*)
" I visited El Toro Cafe hoping for the good Mexican food I miss from my hometown, but I was left disappointed with what I received. The salsa had no kick, and the beans tasted incredibly bland. The tacos were just overloaded with cheese, leaving little room for the meat flavor. Service was surprisingly polite, but that didn’t help the fact the food was simply below par. I can’t see myself recommending this place. " (*Curated Review*)
" I came with high expectations for El Toro Cafe, and I'm sorry to say it was largely disappointed. I found the rice very mushy and the tacos nearly tasteless. Even the cheese dip lacked character—almost like it was made from a premade mix instead of something fresh. The servers were nice, but good service can’t rescue poorly prepared dishes. I think it might be better suited for people who aren’t looking for authentic Mexican, as the flavors just fell flat for me. " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (110)
" I’m a huge fan of Mexican food and was looking forward to El Toro Cafe after hearing some locals rave about it. The atmosphere is cozy, but sadly, the food was underwhelming. I ordered Huevos Rancheros, and it was lacking the spices usually found in genuine Mexican cuisine. The rice was overcooked, and even the quality of the beans was disappointing. While the portions were adequate, I wish the flavors had been more vibrant. I can’t see myself returning anytime soon, unfortunately. " (*Curated Review*)
" I've been to El Toro Cafe multiple times, but the quality of food really varies. On my last visit, the enchiladas were just swiming in cheese but lacked any of the genuine flavors I expect from Mexican cuisine. The staff is generally courteous, but once you taste the food, it overshadows any positive service you receive. I feel like the charm of the place is overshadowed by inconsistent cooking. I wish for better representation of Mexican dishes here. " (*Curated Review*)
Have been to El Toro Cafe? Share your experience with other people!
Explore Other Cuisines Near Newton, Kansas 67114
Top rated nearby
Address: 214 E 12th St, Newton, KS 67114, USA
Address: 2305 S Kansas Ave, Newton, KS 67114, USA
Address: 1607 N Main St, Newton, KS 67114, USA
Address: 217 W Broadway St, Newton, KS 67114, USA
Address: 301 N Meridian Rd, Newton, KS 67114, USA
Address: 427 SE 10th St, Newton, KS 67114, USA
Address: 2406 N Anderson Ave, Newton, KS 67114, USA
Address: 1403 N Main St, Newton, KS 67114, USA