Carini Pizza
Pizza Restaurant
3.9
(76)
Carini Pizza has garnered a reputation for serving authentic New York-style pizza, with many patrons appreciating the quality and flavors reminiscent of traditional pizzerias. While the food is widely praised, some customers have reported inconsistent service and a lack of hospitality from the staff.
Phone number: (845) 252-3338
Address: 112 Kirks Rd, Narrowsburg, NY 12764, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" Carini Pizza is a wonderful gem! I went there the other day craving something delicious and satisfying. The atmosphere has a cozy and nostalgic feel to it, reminding me of small family-run pizzerias back in the city. The owner came off a little strict, but you can tell he cares about his craft. I had a simple cheese pizza, but the quality was exceptional! The cheese was melted to perfection, and the delicate sauce was delightful. The portions were generous for the price. I would recommend this place to anyone looking for an authentic slice of New York-style pizza! " (*Curated Review*)
" I had a somewhat disappointing experience at Carini Pizza. There was a bit of a mix-up with my order, but the owner was quite apologetic about it. The pizza tasted fine, although I expected something more authentic and remarkable given the high reviews. I could sense a lack of customer engagement from him, which could use improvement. That said, I plan on trying again in hopes of a better experience. " (*Curated Review*)
" After frequenting Carini Pizza multiple times, I’d have to say it’s a bit inconsistent. Each time I’ve visited, sometimes the pizza is perfect, thin, and crispy while on other occasions, it’s been less appealing. There seems to be a lack of consistency with the service; some days it’s acceptable, and other days it’s lacking. I do love the flavors when they hit, but I just wish it could be more steady every time. " (*Curated Review*)
" Undoubtedly, Carini Pizza serves some of the best pizza I’ve had outside of New York City. As a native New Yorker, I can be pretty picky about my pizza, but this place delivers. I tried their Margherita pizza, and it instantly transported me back home. The combination of fresh mozzarella, basil, and a beautifully baked crust was simply flawless. Now, I must bring up the service, which can be hit or miss. During my first visit, I encountered a rather grumpy owner, but I’ve also experienced a friendlier visit where I felt welcomed. Regardless, the food quality is motivation enough to return! " (*Curated Review*)
" A solid choice for pizza lovers! Carini Pizza has a straightforward menu with enough variety to keep things interesting. I loved their pepperoni pizza—classic. While the service was a bit underwhelming, the pizza made up for it. No frills, just good NY pizza. I would probably return, especially if I’m in the area again. " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (62)
" Wow, what a pleasant experience I had at Carini Pizza! The pizza was phenomenal! The crust was really thin, which is how I like it, and the flavor was just divine. It’s clear they use high-quality ingredients. Though the service seemed a bit disjointed, the food made up for it. An excellent find, and I plan to visit often! " (*Curated Review*)
" Had a classic pepperoni pie at Carini Pizza earlier this week, and it was pretty good. The crust had a nice crunch and was well-cooked. However, the overall vibe felt a bit off. The owner was all business without much friendliness. Still, I’ll never say no to pizza, and I would give this place another shot! " (*Curated Review*)