Italian Restaurant
4.8 (107)
The Italian American Club has built a reputation for its authentic Italian-American dishes, with many customers raving about the quality and taste of the food. The restaurant's cozy and welcoming atmosphere adds to the overall dining experience, making it a popular choice among locals. The thoughtful service and large portion sizes enhance the value of the dining experience, though a few reviews hint at occasional inconsistencies, particularly with sauce flavors.
Address: 157 Grant St, Waynesburg, OH 44688, USA
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" I've been coming to this restaurant ever since I first tasted their garlic bread. We always feel welcomed as soon as we arrive. The broiled fish is a weekly standout for us, but honestly, every visit comes with great service and comfort. This is the kind of place where you feel part of a community. The portions are just right – not overwhelming, but satisfying enough to leave you feeling full. If you haven’t visited yet, you’re truly missing out! " (*Curated Review*)
" While my first visit was delightful, it seems the quality has fluctuated recently. Last week, I ordered the spaghetti and meatballs, excited as I had heard so much about it. It was good but didn't quite reach the heights I was expecting. The meatballs were a bit drier than I remembered. On the other hand, my friend had the broiled cod, and she loved it. I appreciate the staff’s friendliness and the relaxation of being able to bring my own drinks, but I hope my next visit will be back to their usual high standards. " (*Curated Review*)
" I visited the Italian American Club multiple times, and I've mostly enjoyed my experiences. The garlic bread is standout, and you can taste the freshness in their salads. I had a pizza last time, and while it was good, I've had better elsewhere. The prices are excellent, and the atmosphere is friendly and laid-back. I love the fact that you can bring your beer. Overall, it’s a great spot for casual dining, but don’t expect gourmet. " (*Curated Review*)
" What a lovely evening we spent at the Italian American Club! We celebrated our anniversary there and enjoyed the delightful atmosphere. The food was good but not exceptional; some dishes were better than others. I thoroughly loved the steak, while my partner’s pasta was just average. However, the service was attentive and friendly, and we appreciated their efforts to make our night special. I'd suggest trying a few new dishes next time! " (*Curated Review*)
" I stumbled upon the Italian American Club while searching for local eateries and I’m so glad I did! The Italian dishes here are packed with flavor, and I was taken back by how cozy the setting is. The steak I had was juicy, charred perfectly, and paired wonderfully with their homemade sauce. The price is right, and the staff were kind and accommodating. If you want to experience true Italian comfort food, you will not regret dining here! " (*Curated Review*)
" Let me tell you about the Italian American Club. This place is a treasure for anyone looking to enjoy home-cooked Italian dishes without the frills. Their meatballs are huge and flavor-packed, easily one of the best I've had. The charm of the restaurant lies in its nothing-fancy decor, just a comfortable vibe where friends and family can gather. Their steak sandwich is another gem that’s not to be missed. However, don't come expecting a gourmet establishment; instead, think of it as gathering around the table with loved ones enjoying comfort food. I'll definitely return for more! " (*Curated Review*)
" I recently celebrated my birthday at the Italian American Club, and it was simply fantastic! From the moment we walked in, the smell of delicious food greeted us. I loved the broiled fish, which was flaky and light, paired perfectly with their garlic bread that’s to die for! The staff, particularly Mickey, were warm and attentive, making us feel special. The portions were generous, and we really enjoyed sharing a bottle of wine we brought along. I highly recommend this restaurant for its authentic vibe and quality dishes. Can’t wait to return! " (*Curated Review*)
Address: 134 W Lisbon St, Waynesburg, OH 44688, USA
Address: 164 N Main St, Magnolia, OH 44643, USA
Address: 144 N Main St, Magnolia, OH 44643, USA
Address: 111 N Reed Ave, Malvern, OH 44644, USA