Old Mexico Bar & Grill
Mexican Restaurant
4.5
(314)
Old Mexico Bar & Grill is largely embraced for its commitment to providing authentic Mexican cuisine in a friendly and welcoming atmosphere. Diners often mention the quality and freshness of the dishes, especially highlighting the steak and enchiladas. While service tends to be commendable, some customers experienced inconsistencies during busy periods. Overall, the restaurant is considered a gem in the area, attracting both locals and visitors alike.
Phone number: (478) 458-0090
Address: 127 Cherry St, Montezuma, GA 31063, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" I particularly loved the Quesadilla at Old Mexico Bar & Grill—the cheese was creamy and the flavors blended beautifully. However, my partner's steak was overcooked and they didn’t seem to handle it well when we mentioned it to the staff. They were friendly but the follow-up could have been better to ensure we were satisfied. Overall, I think I’ll keep trying this place out as it has a lot of potential. " (*Curated Review*)
" Disappointed with my experience at Old Mexico Bar & Grill. Although the ambiance was nice, the food didn't quite meet my expectations. I ordered the Seafood Burrito and it was lukewarm, which was a letdown. I mentioned it to the staff, but the response was less than satisfactory. I wanted to love this restaurant based on all the hype, but I left feeling underwhelmed. Hopefully, I just caught them on an off night. " (*Curated Review*)
" Had a very mixed experience at Old Mexico Bar & Grill. The soup was really good, but the tacos lacked flavor and seemed bland. The waiter was kind but a bit slow to check on us. I just feel like it had a lot of potential but missed the mark for me overall. Still, I might come back to give it a second chance, as my friends enjoyed it. " (*Curated Review*)
" Passing through Montezuma and decided to stop by Old Mexico Bar & Grill. Great call! The food was authentic and flavorful. I had the fajitas, and they were sizzling and exactly what I wanted. The service was decent, but the place got quite packed. I can understand some delays, but it was not too bad. I’ll definitely be back to try more dishes! " (*Curated Review*)
" I had the worst experience here last Friday. The server was forgetful and my order was wrong when it finally arrived after more than an hour. I ordered chicken enchiladas but got beef instead, which I can’t eat. The restaurant wasn’t too crowded, so I don’t understand the delay. It was frustrating, and though I liked the food I'd previously had, this experience might keep me from coming back. " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (253)
" Old Mexico Bar & Grill is a fantastic spot! We had a great family dinner there, and everyone left happy. The atmosphere was buzzing and lively, which added to the charm. For vegetarian options, their quesadillas and salsa verde are a must-try! Service was friendly, but it took longer than expected for our main courses to arrive. Will definitely return soon! " (*Curated Review*)
" Our dining experience at Old Mexico Bar & Grill had its ups and downs. The ambiance was warm and inviting but the service lagged a bit, especially during peak hours. The highlight was definitely the food; everything we ordered was bursting with classic flavors. I recommend their grilled shrimp tacos! I would give them another shot on a less busy day. " (*Curated Review*)