Papa Carlo Pizzeria & Gelati

" Last week, I decided to host a small get-together at home and ordered pizzas from Papa Carlo's. They had great service during my phone order, and the pizzas arrived right on time. However, I was disappointed when I opened the boxes. The toppings were sparse and the crusts were hard, almost like they had been overcooked. It felt like I got less than what I paid for, as I spent quite a bit for what I thought would be a great feast. I'm not sure if I will return after this experience, but I appreciated the promptness of the delivery staff. My friends who were over were also underwhelmed and it made for an awkward dinner party. " (*Curated Review*)

×

" Taking a chance on a new place can be a gamble, but Papa Carlo’s was a great find! I absolutely loved their Margherita pizza. The fresh ingredients really stood out and the crust was thin yet durable enough to hold everything together. Even the sauce had a lovely balance of flavors. The overall atmosphere felt warm and inviting, which made the dinner even more enjoyable. I have to commend the staff, too, they were incredibly attentive without being overbearing. I’ll be back sooner rather than later! " (*Curated Review*)

×

" Visited Papa Carlo's upon my friend's strong recommendation and it didn’t disappoint! The margherita pizza was phenomenal—light and flavorful crust adorned with fresh basil and mozzarella. I also savored their homemade gelato for dessert, which was a delightful end to the meal. The staff was attentive, and the atmosphere was vibrant and welcoming. I can't wait to share this spot with more friends and family soon! Definitely a must-visit if you're a pizza lover! " (*Curated Review*)

×

" Last month, I had a not-so-great experience at Papa Carlo's. The atmosphere was lively and attractive which was certainly a bonus. However, my pizza was lacking in the flavor department—quite bland and boring. To make matters worse, we were waiting a long time for our food, which took away from our experience. I was looking forward to a tasty dining but came away feeling disappointed. It was a busy night, so perhaps that played a role, but I would still expect better. I might drop by again to give it another try, primarily for their desserts which seemed enticing. " (*Curated Review*)

×

" Papa Carlo's has been a favorite destination for our family for years. Each time we stop by, we know we won’t be disappointed. Their pizzas are always made fresh, and they even toss the dough in front of you—what fun! The flavor combinations they offer are unique and delicious. My personal favorite is the white cream sauce that just adds a special touch to the whole experience. The service has always been friendly, which certainly encourages us to keep coming back. Remember to save room for gelato; they offer some delightful flavors! " (*Curated Review*)

×

" I stumbled upon Papa Carlo's while driving through Lockport, and I'm so glad I did! The pizza was absolutely incredible, especially the Mama Anna Deluxe. It was packed with flavor and made with fresh ingredients that truly made the difference. The crust was perfectly baked, not too thick, but substantial enough to hold everything together. The service was fast and friendly, making the experience even better. Definitely a place I'd return to again and again! My only wish is that they had a few more vegetarian options on the menu to choose from. Overall, a fantastic place for anyone who loves great pizza! " (*Curated Review*)

×

" My family tried Papa Carlo's for the first time last week, and we were blown away! We were promptly seated and the atmosphere felt friendly and warm. I decided to order the pasta and I was pleasantly surprised at how fresh it tasted. My husband stuck with pizza and claimed it was the best he’d had in a long time. The desserts looked incredible too, but we didn't save room after indulging in our meals. I highly recommend trying this spot if you're ever in the area; it’s surely worth visiting again! " (*Curated Review*)

×