Goodfella's Pizza Italian Restaurant

Italian Restaurant $$ 4.1 (563)

Goodfella's Pizza Italian Restaurant is celebrated for its authentic Italian dishes, especially the pizza, which resonates with customers who appreciate flavors reminiscent of classic Italian cooking. The ambiance is inviting, yet service quality varies, with some patrons mentioning delays or inattentiveness. The generous portion sizes relative to the pricing are frequently highlighted, making it a popular choice for families and gatherings.

Overall:

4.5

(462 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.4

Atmosphere:

4.2

Service:

3.8

Restaurant website: Website

Phone number: (570) 491-8191

Address: 111 Hulst Dr, Matamoras, PA 18336, USA

Opening hours

Monday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Thursday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Sunday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM

Photo gallery

Service options

  • Dine-In Available
  • Takeout Available
  • Delivery Available
  • Curbside Pickup Available
  • Reservable

Offerings

  • Brunch
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Beer
  • Wine
  • Cocktails
  • Dessert
  • Coffee
  • Vegetarian Options Available

Amenities

  • Outdoor Seating
  • Restroom Available

Good for

  • Menu for Children
  • Good for Children
  • Good for Groups
  • Good for Watching Sports

Payment options

  • Credit Cards
  • Debit Cards
  • NFC Payments

Parking options

  • Free Parking Lot
  • Free Street Parking

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair Accessible Parking
  • Wheelchair Accessible Entrance
  • Wheelchair Accessible Restroom
  • Wheelchair Accessible Seating

Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)

**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**

" The experience I had at Goodfella's wasn't quite what I was expecting. The pizza was tasty, but the service was noticeably absent as we waited a long time to place our order. The restaurant was crowded, but a little more attentiveness would have gone a long way. " (*Curated Review*)

9 months ago

" Last night, I attended a family gathering at Goodfella's, and I have to commend them on their handling of our sizable group. The servers were attentive, bringing out the food quickly without a hitch. I tried their pasta primavera, and it was packed with fresh vegetables and flavors. Good place for large family outings! " (*Curated Review*)

10 months ago

" This was my second visit, and I enjoyed the food just as much as the first time. The stuffed shells were fantastic! The only downside was that our waiter was a bit slow, but the food made it worthwhile. " (*Curated Review*)

10 months ago

" I have been coming to Goodfella's for years, and the place continues to impress. The food is always fresh, tasty, and portions are immense! A go-to for me whenever I'm craving Italian food. " (*Curated Review*)

5 months ago

" Just had the most delightful dinner at Goodfella's! The margherita pizza was a piece of heaven. The crust was perfectly crispy and the tomato sauce was bursting with flavors. I could taste the freshness of the basil and mozzarella. Overall, a fantastic dining experience! " (*Curated Review*)

11 months ago

Archived Reviews (452)

" The pasta salad I had was decent, but the service was lackluster. I felt ignored during my visit. I don't believe I will return again as the experience left a lot to be desired. " (*Curated Review*)

6 months ago

" Had an amazing time at Goodfella's! Our pizza was super cheesy, and the staff were incredibly friendly. They made our evening enjoyable. I can't recommend it enough! " (*Curated Review*)

7 months ago
More reviews not shown...

Have been to Goodfella's Pizza Italian Restaurant? Share your experience with other people!

Please enter at least 15 characters.
no selection

Explore Other Cuisines Near Matamoras, Pennsylvania 18336

Top rated nearby

Sushi Teriyaki
Japanese Restaurant

Overall:

4.3

(147 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.1

Atmosphere:

4.1

Service:

3.8

Address: 111 Hulst Dr, Matamoras, PA 18336, USA
3Ninja Express
Japanese Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.5

(152 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.1

Atmosphere:

4.1

Service:

4.1

Address: 2 E Main St, Port Jervis, NY 12771, USA
Peking Garden Restaurant
Chinese Restaurant $

Overall:

4.1

(187 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.1

Atmosphere:

3.5

Service:

3.9

Address: 111 Hulst Dr #711, Matamoras, PA 18336, USA
El Patron Mexican Restaurant
Mexican Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.5

(1215 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.3

Atmosphere:

4.4

Service:

4.0

Address: 104 US-6, Port Jervis, NY 12771, USA
La Posada & Felix Cantina
Mexican Restaurant

Overall:

4.5

(178 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.5

Atmosphere:

4.3

Service:

4.2

Address: 210 2nd St, Milford, PA 18337, USA
Tequila Sunrise
Mexican Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.7

(334 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.7

Atmosphere:

4.5

Service:

4.6

Address: 305 E Harford St, Milford, PA 18337, USA
Front Street Café
Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.5

(216 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.2

Atmosphere:

4.1

Service:

4.1

Address: 78 Front St #58, Port Jervis, NY 12771, USA
Franico's Pizzeria & Trattoria
Pizza Restaurant $

Overall:

4.0

(172 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.1

Atmosphere:

4.1

Service:

3.7

Address: 302 Pennsylvania Ave, Matamoras, PA 18336, USA
Carini Cucina E Pizzeria
Pizza Restaurant $

Overall:

4.4

(183 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.2

Atmosphere:

3.8

Service:

4.1

Address: 203 6th St, Milford, PA 18337, USA
Good Friends Chinese Restaurant
Chinese Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.2

(211 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.0

Atmosphere:

3.3

Service:

4.0

Address: 181 Pike St, Port Jervis, NY 12771, USA