The Original PJ's Pizza - New Martinsville

" I finally had to try the famous PJ's pizza after hearing so much about it. What a disappointment it turned out to be. The crust was tough, and the sauce tasted almost bland. I had high hopes as I compared it to other pizzas I've had. The overall pizza appeared to be hastily put together, and I couldn't even finish my meal. There are just too many good pizza places in the area that deserve recognition over this. I’d rather choose something a little more authentic. " (*Curated Review*)

×

" I used to love PJ's pizza, but it feels like they’ve cut a lot of corners recently. I ordered my usual and it arrived looking a bit sad—barely any cheese and sparse toppings. I can understand busy hours causing some mistakes, but the flavor has drastically decreased. They serve their food without the same enthusiasm they used to, which really affects the experience. I left feeling quite underwhelmed. " (*Curated Review*)

×

" Seriously, I had low expectations going into PJ's Pizza after hearing mixed reviews, but wow, color me impressed! The crust was perfectly cooked, and the toppings were incredible. It feels so fresh compared to other chains I've tried. The staff were friendly and attentive, which completed my experience nicely. I'll be coming back for sure, particularly to try their specialty dishes. " (*Curated Review*)

×

" On a recent visit, I decided on the PJ Special pizza, and I was pleasantly surprised this time! The cheese was gooey, the toppings were plentiful, and it felt more authentic than I experienced on prior visits. The wait wasn't long at all and my pizza was prepared on time. Friendly atmosphere! I’d say this visit redeemed the restaurant slightly, giving me hope for my next order. I might go back again to give it another shot. " (*Curated Review*)

×

" Had a group order for a game night, and though my friends raved about PJ's in the past, we were met with a lackluster experience. The pizzas came out lukewarm, and the toppings were nowhere near what we expected. It felt like a rush job during a busy evening. The service was hit or miss; our interaction was fine, but I got distracted by how many other customers had issues too. Overall, not the best! Might try somewhere else next time. " (*Curated Review*)

×

" This was my first time trying PJ's and I went with skepticism due to the mixed reviews. To my surprise, my pepperoni pizza arrived hot and savory. The toppings were abundant, and the crust had a satisfying crunch without being overly greasy. I will definitely be back if they maintain this level of quality. Friendly staff sealed the deal for me making for a nice experience overall. " (*Curated Review*)

×

" Due to previous feedback, I was skeptical about my visit to PJ's Pizza. However, after sampling their works pizza, I must say that I left pleasantly surprised! The proportions were generous, and the flavors were delicious. It felt nice to sit and enjoy my meal rather than rush through it. Definitely eyeing some new specialty items next visit based on this experience. " (*Curated Review*)

×