Peppino's Pizza, LLC
Pizza Restaurant
4.5
(90)
Peppino's Pizza is known for its homemade pasta and pizza, emphasizing authentic Italian recipes that resonate well with many diners. While the service and ambiance generally receive praise, there are some criticisms regarding certain menu items and inconsistency in availability, which detracts slightly from the overall experience.
Phone number: (715) 582-4999
Address: W4343 Stibbe Ln, Peshtigo, WI 54157, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" Visiting Peppino's feels like stepping into a family gathering. The staff treats every diner like a regular, and the food is always comforting. I had a simple cheese pizza and appreciated the quality of the cheese—a true cut above typical fast-food pizza. Each bite was filled with flavor, and the crust had just the right texture. It’s not ultra-fancy, and I like it that way! Definitely one of my go-to spots for pizza! " (*Curated Review*)
" Peppino's Pizza is a gem! Their garlic knots are the perfect appetizer, and the marinara sauce complements them beautifully. I absolutely love their stuffed crust pizza, which is a must-try! The service is courteous and friendly, which makes you feel at home. On prices, I think it’s reasonable when you consider how generous their portions are. Only drawback was we had to wait for seating on a Friday night! Still worth it! " (*Curated Review*)
" I was skeptical trying Peppino's at first because of the mixed reviews, but I really enjoyed my time there. The food was good, and I'd say the authenticity stood out to me. My lasagna was really hearty, and you could tell it was made fresh. The décor is simple but inviting! My only complaint was occasional delays due to busy servers, but it wasn’t a deal-breaker. I'd be willing to come back without hesitation. " (*Curated Review*)
" Peppino's Pizza provides a unique dining experience, as the concept revolves around storytelling with every dish. I had their lasagna, and it was clear that each layer was made with care. The flavors melded beautifully together, which showed how authentic the recipes are compared to many other places in town. Service was friendly, and the environment felt homely, despite it being busy. Options available for everyone, including gluten-free dishes! I'd happily recommend to anyone looking for quality Italian fare. " (*Curated Review*)
" My friends and I visited Peppino's last week. Despite the chaos of a busy Saturday night, the food came out quite promptly. I had a slice of their signature pizza which was really wonderful! The ingredients felt fresh, but the balance of flavors could improve. The interior setup is quite standard and homey, suitable for both casual and celebratory meals. Service could have been better, but still a pleasant outing overall. " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (74)
" I am a huge pasta fan, and I must say Peppino's did not disappoint! I ordered the fettuccine alfredo with their homemade sauce, and it was incredibly rich and creamy. However, I was a little disappointed that they had changed the recipe as I remembered it being homemade Alfredo sauce, and I found this version to be lacking in flavor. The ambiance of the restaurant is cozy, and the staff is generally friendly, but there is room for improvement on couple of dishes. Overall, still worth the trip! " (*Curated Review*)
" We tried Peppino's for the first time while visiting the area and were pleasantly surprised by the quality of the meals! The pizza was incredibly flavorful and loaded with toppings, though we did feel that the portion could have been a bit larger for the price. The ambiance was charming, not overly fancy, just a nice spot to enjoy a meal. Our server was friendly but seemed a little rushed. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone craving good pizza! " (*Curated Review*)