Il Castello Pizzeria e Ristorante
Pizza Restaurant
$
4.5
(395)
Il Castello Pizzeria e Ristorante is highly praised for its authentic Italian cuisine, especially its pizza and pasta dishes. Many customers note the freshness and care in preparation, giving it a strong reputation for authenticity. The service is generally attentive, and the portions are substantial relative to the pricing, making it a favorite among both locals and visitors.
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (845) 557-6400
Address: 3438 NY-97, Barryville, NY 12719, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" The food was good but unfortunately the service was lacking. We waited quite a long time for our order, and when it arrived, it was mixed up. I had the chicken marsala, which was good, but I expected it to be lighter based on other reviews. Overall, I think they have potential, but they need to improve on their service aspect to match the quality of their food. " (*Curated Review*)
" Had a mixed experience at Il Castello. The pizza was satisfying, but I had lower expectations when it came to service. Our server seemed overwhelmed and wasn't present when we needed assistance. But the food ultimately redeemed our experience! A good place for a casual evening, but I hope to see a more attentive staff in future visits. " (*Curated Review*)
" I visited Il Castello with my family on a busy Saturday, and although the wait was long, the staff kept us entertained and informed throughout. I ordered the seafood pasta, which was a delightful surprise with plenty of fresh ingredients. However, they could improve their pasta offerings based on previous reviews. Overall, a worthwhile experience, and I know we'll be back to try the pizza! " (*Curated Review*)
" The pastas at Il Castello blew my mind! The flavors were true Italian, and I appreciated the size of the portions. My only complaint would be the ambiance; it could use some uplift. Overall, I had a wonderful time, and I'm eager to return, especially for the gnocchi next time. " (*Curated Review*)
" I was initially looking forward to dining here, but I left feeling a bit let down. Don't get me wrong, the pizza was decent, but I question the authenticity of some dishes. The lasagna felt too commercialized for my taste, lacking that homemade flavor one hopes for. The staff were polite but somewhat slow during service. Overall, I'd say it's okay but not what I expected. I might give it another shot in the future, but I won’t be rushing back. " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (318)
" The stuffed pizza was a fantastic choice! Juicy fillings and a delightful crust made it a standout dish. I also enjoyed their signature salad bar, full of fresh toppings. However, the restaurant was quite busy, and thus our orders took longer than expected. Overall, a solid experience as the food made up for the wait time. " (*Curated Review*)
" The food was solid but not exceptional. I had the veggie pizza, which had great toppings but was somewhat soggy at the bottom. The atmosphere was inviting, but I faced delays in the service. While people rave about this place, my experience was okay at best. I might return to try something different but nothing is drawing me back immediately. " (*Curated Review*)