Most Authentic Italian Restaurants near Water Mill, New York 11976

1. American Pie

Open until 9:00 PM

4.8 overall · 198 reviews

Pizza Restaurant

2044 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton, NY 11932, USA

2. Pellegrino's Pizza Bar & Restaurant

Open until 9:00 PM

4.5 overall · 155 reviews

Italian Restaurant · $$

1271 Noyack Rd, Southampton, NY 11968, USA

3. Sant Ambroeus Southampton

Open until 9:00 PM

4.6 overall · 379 reviews

Italian Restaurant · $$$

30 Main St, Southampton, NY 11968, USA

4. La Parmigiana

Open until 9:00 PM

4.4 overall · 364 reviews

Italian Restaurant · $$

44-48 NY-27A, Southampton, NY 11968, USA

5. Dopo Argento

Open until 9:00 PM

4.5 overall · 104 reviews

Italian Restaurant

15 Main St, Southampton, NY 11968, USA

6. Tutto Il Giorno South

Open until 10:00 PM

4.5 overall · 267 reviews

Italian Restaurant · $$$

56 Nugent St, Southampton, NY 11968, USA

7. Cappelletti Restaurant & Take Out

Open until 9:00 PM

4.5 overall · 267 reviews

Italian Restaurant · $$

3284 Noyack Rd, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, USA