Most Authentic Italian Restaurants near Shirley, New York 11967

1. La Margherita Pizzeria

Open until 10:00 PM

4.9 overall · 906 reviews

Italian Restaurant · $$

1231 Station Rd, Medford, NY 11763, USA

2. Mama Lisa Restaurant

Open until 10:30 PM

4.5 overall · 1376 reviews

Italian Restaurant · $$

1226 Montauk Hwy, Mastic, NY 11950, USA

3. La Volpe Restaurant & Anton Pizzeria

Open until 10:30 PM

4.6 overall · 648 reviews

Pizza Restaurant · $$

611 Montauk Hwy, Center Moriches, NY 11934, USA

4. Avino's Italian Table

Open until 11:00 PM

4.6 overall · 384 reviews

Italian Restaurant · $$

108 S Country Rd, Bellport, NY 11713, USA

5. Brothers Four Pizza

Open until 11:00 PM

4.6 overall · 251 reviews

Pizza Restaurant · $

310 Main St, Center Moriches, NY 11934, USA

6. Capio's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Open until 9:30 PM

4.5 overall · 203 reviews

Pizza Restaurant

1259 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953, USA

7. Onofrio's

Open until 10:00 PM

4.6 overall · 201 reviews

Italian Restaurant · $$

421 Neighborhood Rd, Mastic Beach, NY 11951, USA