Most Authentic Italian Restaurants near Middle Island, New York 11953

1. La Margherita Pizzeria

Closed · opens 10:30 AM

4.9 overall · 906 reviews

Italian Restaurant · $$

1231 Station Rd, Medford, NY 11763, USA

2. Tony’s on the boulevard

Closed · opens 11:00 AM

4.8 overall · 74 reviews

Italian Restaurant · $$

175 Sound Beach Blvd, Sound Beach, NY 11789, USA

3. Marinelli’s Pizzeria and Restaurant

Closed · opens 10:00 AM

4.7 overall · 127 reviews

Pizza Restaurant · $$

257 Echo Ave, Sound Beach, NY 11789, USA

4. Mavi Grill - Turkish & Mediterranean Cuisine

Closed · opens 11:00 AM

4.8 overall · 308 reviews

Turkish Restaurant · $$

749 Mount Sinai-Coram Rd, Mt Sinai, NY 11766, USA

5. Tony's Pizza

Closed · opens 11:00 AM

4.7 overall · 428 reviews

Pizza Restaurant · $

2277 NY-112, Medford, NY 11763, USA

6. Mama Lisa Restaurant

Closed · opens 11:00 AM

4.5 overall · 1376 reviews

Italian Restaurant · $$

1226 Montauk Hwy, Mastic, NY 11950, USA

7. Savino's Hideaway

Closed · opens 12:00 PM

4.6 overall · 861 reviews

Italian Restaurant · $$

258 N Country Rd, Mt Sinai, NY 11766, USA