The Incredible Pizza Co
Permanently closed
Pizza Restaurant
$$
3.2
(323)
The Incredible Pizza Co has mixed feedback regarding its food quality and service. Customers have mentioned issues with authenticity and consistency in the preparation of dishes. Many have expressed disappointment with the service experience, while the late-night availability is seen as a convenience.
Closed · opens 4:00 PM
Hours from Google · may not reflect holidays or recent changes
Phone number: (740) 345-4455
Address: 391 W Main St, Newark, OH 43055, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" I have ordered from here multiple times usually late at night since it's one of the few places available then. The consistency varies, which can be frustrating. Sometimes the pizza is really good, while other times it's noticeably lacking flavor. I had a particularly odd experience where my delivery took over 2 hours, and when it arrived, the pizza was cold. They need to work on their speed and overall customer service. It's a shame because the potential is definitely there! " (*Curated Review*)
" The only thing going for them is their late hours. The quality of the food isn’t anything to brag about, and most of the time I can't even finish what's on my plate. It's like they're serving leftovers sometimes. I wish they could use fresher ingredients or at least serve something that doesn't feel old and stale. " (*Curated Review*)
" This place has potential but just needs to work on its execution. The pizza variety is appealing, but the taste just doesn’t hold up. I find myself wondering if they care about quality, especially at such late hours. The first time I ordered was better than the rest, but every subsequent experience has disappointed me. Hoping for something better next time. " (*Curated Review*)
" I can't quite decide how I feel about this place. The pizza was decent, but I find the subs really hit-or-miss. I like that they stay open late, but honestly, the food is inconsistent. One time it was fantastic, and the next, it felt like a different place altogether. It’s a good backup when I have no other options, but I wouldn't make it my first choice. " (*Curated Review*)
" I’ve been going here for late-night subs for a while now because of their hours. The Italian sub was decent but sometimes they skimp on the fillings. I’ve had hit-or-miss experiences, so I’m always taking a gamble when I order. The service has been friendly on most occasions, but delays in getting my food have been common. This restaurant does offer a unique niche being open late, though it could use some improvements. " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (260)
" This pizza place saved me from hunger when I arrived at midnight! The staff was friendly and helpful and the prices were fair. What I received was of decent quality for a late-night snack. I would certainly recommend this place to others looking for food at odd hours, as long as they keep their expectations modest. " (*Curated Review*)
" Not impressed at all. The delivery was late, the food was cold, and I feel like I overpaid for what I got. There was no sauce on my pizza, and when I called the restaurant, they didn’t seem to care much. I think it’s time to find someplace else to order from. " (*Curated Review*)
Have been to The Incredible Pizza Co? Share your experience with other people!
Explore Other Cuisines Near Newark, Ohio 43055
Top rated nearby
Address: 661 S 30th St, Heath, OH 43056, USA
Address: 1006 Hebron Rd C, Heath, OH 43056, USA
Address: 417 Mt Vernon Rd, Newark, OH 43055, USA
Address: 957 Hebron Rd, Heath, OH 43056, USA
Address: 1485 Granville Rd, Newark, OH 43055, USA
Address: 16 W Main St, Newark, OH 43055, USA
Address: 869 Hebron Rd, Heath, OH 43056, USA
Address: 898 Hebron Rd, Heath, OH 43056, USA
Address: 1230 W Church St, Newark, OH 43055, USA
Address: 1225 W Church St, Newark, OH 43055, USA