New Brother's Pizza
Pizza Restaurant
$
4.5
(262)
New Brother's Pizza is celebrated for its authentic pizza and diverse menu that resonates with the tastes of classic Italian-American cuisine. Many customers appreciate the freshness of the ingredients and the authentic flavors that remind them of New York-style pizza. The service is generally regarded as friendly, though some have reported inconsistencies on busy days. Overall, it is a popular spot worth revisiting.
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (540) 949-8900
Address: 2006 Jefferson Hwy, Fishersville, VA 22939, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" I can't rave enough about New Brother's Pizza. The moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm smile by the staff, and the aroma of fresh pizza filled the air. I ordered a classic pepperoni pizza, and it was nothing short of phenomenal. The crust was perfectly crispy, the sauce had the right amount of zing, and the pepperoni was so flavorful! I also tried their garlic knots, which were soft and garlicky—just how I like them. My friends had the wings, and they couldn't stop praising them either. This place is a gem, and I will definitely be returning soon! " (*Curated Review*)
" My recent dinner at New Brother's Pizza was a bit disappointing. The pasta was overcooked and lacked flavor, which surprised me since I'd always heard great things about their food. The service was acceptable, but I noticed they seemed more focused on takeout orders than dining-in customers. It's a busy place, which can be a double-edged sword. It’s still a good option for pizza, but perhaps I'll stick to just pizza next time. " (*Curated Review*)
" New Brother's Pizza is a hidden gem! I discovered this place last month while visiting a friend. The pizza was undeniably the best I’ve had in years! The generous amount of cheese and the sweet sauce made it feel authentically Italian. Our server was really friendly and made great recommendations. The only downside was the wait time, since they also handle a substantial amount of delivery orders, but it was worth it. I look forward to my next meal here! " (*Curated Review*)
" I feel so grateful to have discovered New Brother's Pizza! Their calzone is by far the best I’ve ever tried. The creaminess of the ricotta with all that melty mozzarella is a dream come true. I love stopping by here after work for a quick bite. The atmosphere is fantastic, as is their customer service, which makes it an easy choice for a favorite go-to restaurant! " (*Curated Review*)
" After hearing so many good things about New Brother's Pizza, I finally decided to check it out. The pizza was delicious, but my experience was slightly marred by the long wait for our food. The place was busy, and it seems they were struggling a bit with orders. However, when the food arrived, I was impressed by the quality. The pepperoni pizza had that authentic NY taste, and I can’t wait to give them another shot on a less busy night. " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (211)
" New Brother's Pizza has become a staple for our family pizza nights. We usually order multiple pizzas and wings, and everything is consistently delicious. I appreciate that they offer a good variety of toppings and their crust is always fresh. I’ve tried other pizza places nearby, but none compares to the flavor and texture here. Plus, their delivery is usually super fast, which is a major plus when you’re starving. Highly recommend trying the white pizza; it’s my personal favorite! " (*Curated Review*)
" New Brother's Pizza has become my favorite place for late-night cravings. Their garlic knots are to die for, and the pizza is always loaded with toppings. It's been a reliable source of good food whether I dine-in or get it delivered. The staff is usually quite friendly. However, on one occasion, I had a slight mix-up with my order, but the manager quickly corrected it, which I appreciated. Every experience has been mostly great, and I highly recommend this spot! " (*Curated Review*)
Have been to New Brother's Pizza? Share your experience with other people!
Explore Other Cuisines Near Fishersville, Virginia 22939
Top rated nearby
Address: 325 E Main St, Waynesboro, VA 22980, USA
Address: 250 E Main St, Waynesboro, VA 22980, USA
Address: 32 Windward Dr, Fishersville, VA 22939, USA
Address: 1027 Richmond Rd, Staunton, VA 24401, USA
Address: 2120 W Main St, Waynesboro, VA 22980, USA
Address: 401 N Poplar Ave C, Waynesboro, VA 22980, USA
Address: 2284 Jefferson Hwy STE 102, Fishersville, VA 22939, USA
Address: 2556 Jefferson Hwy, Waynesboro, VA 22980, USA
Address: 109 Lew Dewitt Blvd C, Waynesboro, VA 22980, USA
Address: 2576 Stuarts Draft Hwy, Stuarts Draft, VA 24477, USA