Old Town Pizza
Pizza Restaurant
$$
4.1
(386)
Old Town Pizza offers a diverse menu with a focus on authentic Italian flavors, evidenced by positive remarks about their pizza and pasta dishes. While food quality is generally praised, service can be hit or miss, with some customers citing poor experiences. Overall, the restaurant enjoys a favorable reputation among locals, making it a go-to spot for takeout and casual dining.
Closed · opens 10:00 AM
Hours from Google · may not reflect holidays or recent changes
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (631) 473-3712
Address: 691 Old Town Rd, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" Old Town Pizza had a bustling vibe that instantly lured me in. I went with my family and shared a variety of dishes, including their famed garlic knots and pizza. While the knots were light and fluffy, their pizza was loaded with toppings and hit the spot. The service was attentive, and our food arrived promptly despite the crowd. My only complaint was the seating, which felt a little cramped but overall a fantastic meal that I'll be returning for! " (*Curated Review*)
" Old Town Pizza has been pretty consistent in quality. I tend to order the same things, usually their signature veggie pizza and garlic knots. Their pizza is large enough to satisfy and the flavor is spot on. The service is always pleasant, though it is often a little crowded, especially during the weekends. My only qualm would be that they sometimes get the order wrong, but they correct it quickly. " (*Curated Review*)
" I've been to Old Town Pizza several times, and each experience has been a mixed bag. The pizza is usually top-notch, especially the pepperoni, crispy and flavorful. However, the service often leaves something to be desired. Once, I had to wait long even though the restaurant was hardly busy. Don't get me wrong, their food is delicious, but the staff can sometimes act as if they’re doing you a favor. Worth a visit if you have time to spare! " (*Curated Review*)
" I decided to order delivery from Old Town Pizza for a movie night. I must say, the garlic knots and the stuffed mushrooms did not disappoint! The garlic knots were fluffy while the mushrooms were packed with flavor. However, I did encounter some issues with my delivery being incomplete. When I called to report the problem, the staff was quite helpful, promising to send over the missing items. It’s comforting to know they care enough to fix mistakes! Would definitely order again, and fingers crossed for a perfect delivery next time. " (*Curated Review*)
" Disappointed is an understatement when it comes to my experience at Old Town Pizza. I was really looking forward to tasting their famed stuffed mushrooms, but they came drenched in what I can only describe as a sludge, not scampi sauce! It was completely inauthentic and ruined my meal. When I brought it to the attention of the staff, I was met with indifference. I left feeling frustrated and unsatisfied. If you're looking for real Italian flavors, I would recommend looking elsewhere. " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (310)
" Got takeout from Old Town Pizza last week. Their specialty pizzas are legendary, I ordered the white pizza with broccoli rabe and I was in heaven! It had the perfect balance of flavors and was very satisfying! When I picked it up, the wait wasn’t too long, and the lady at the counter was very nice. I'll surely be back for more! " (*Curated Review*)
" Old Town Pizza used to be my favorite until my last visit. The pizza was lackluster, and the staff seemed overwhelmed. On top of that, I found the establishment quite noisy, making it hard to enjoy our meal. I’ve noticed a decline over the years, and I’m not sure if I’ll return unless I hear improvements are made. " (*Curated Review*)
Have been to Old Town Pizza? Share your experience with other people!
Explore Other Cuisines Near Port Jefferson Station, New York 11776
Top rated nearby
Address: 175 Sound Beach Blvd, Sound Beach, NY 11789, USA
Address: 257 Echo Ave, Sound Beach, NY 11789, USA
Address: 2320 N Ocean Ave, Farmingville, NY 11738, USA
Address: 389 Independence Plaza, Selden, NY 11784, USA
Address: 2166 Nesconset Hwy, Stony Brook, NY 11790, USA
Address: 654 Horseblock Road, Farmingville, NY 11738, USA
Address: 5507 Nesconset Hwy Suite #16, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776, USA
Address: 1066 Main St, Holbrook, NY 11741, USA
Address: 735 Hawkins Ave, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY 11779, USA
Address: 749 Mount Sinai-Coram Rd, Mt Sinai, NY 11766, USA