Amato's Pizzeria (Newton)
Pizza Restaurant
$
4.3
(150)
Amato's Pizzeria is a local gem that offers a variety of pizzas and Italian dishes. While some customers appreciate the flavors and quality of the food, there are comments regarding the authenticity of certain items. The service is often praised for its friendliness and attentiveness, creating a welcoming atmosphere in the restaurant.
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (973) 383-2727
Address: 55 Mill St Suite 2, Newton, NJ 07860, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" I recently ordered takeout from Amato's and was really pleased! The pizza was so cheesy and flavorful! There was a nice balance of sauce, which is typically a gamble at many places. The staff who handled my order was friendly, and they ensured I got everything correctly packed. If you’re looking for a reliable spot for pizza, this is it. I wouldn’t say the food is 100% authentic as some claim, but it's definitely satisfying! " (*Curated Review*)
" Oh my goodness! Amato's has quickly become my go-to place for pizza! I can't stress enough how authentic their dishes taste. It's hard to find good Italian in Sussex County, but they've nailed it. The eggplant parmesan was delightful, and the pasta was cooked to perfection. Also, their cannoli is a must-try! It's refreshing to see a restaurant that values quality ingredients and service. The atmosphere is casual and inviting; definitely a place I recommend to my friends. " (*Curated Review*)
" After hearing so many good things about Amato's, I finally ordered a pizza for delivery. To my disappointment, it was mediocre at best. While the toppings were decent, the sauce tasted watered down and lacked the richness I expect from Italian pizza. However, the delivery was prompt and the driver was very polite. I might consider giving them another try, but I hope they can improve the sauce. Not the best experience for my first try. " (*Curated Review*)
" A cozy little pizzeria that feels like home! The staff is like family and consistently friendly. My favorite here is the chicken parm pizza, which has just the right amount of cheese and sauce. However, they're sometimes a bit baggy in timing. I ordered at peak hours and still got my food on time, but I’ve seen longer waits. Portions are generous and price-wise, it’s very fair! Looking forward to my next visit! " (*Curated Review*)
" Had a very disappointing experience with the food from Amato's. The pizza was lacking flavor and the pasta tasted more like a boiled dish than anything savory. It felt quite overpriced for what it was. The service was good, but that's not enough to redeem the disappointing meal. I hope others have better luck than I did. " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (122)
" Exceptional pizza and excellent service! We celebrated my son’s birthday here, and the staff went above and beyond. The atmosphere was vibrant and made the occasion even better! The value for what you receive was impressive. I would highly recommend Amato's to anyone looking for a great meal! " (*Curated Review*)
" The pizza at Amato's Pizzeria never fails to impress! I tried the pepperoni pizza, and it was loaded with toppings. The crust was soft yet firm, just how I like it. The portion size was generous, making it a perfect meal for sharing. The service was friendly, and they gave great suggestions for my meal. I will definitely be back to explore more of their menu! " (*Curated Review*)
Have been to Amato's Pizzeria (Newton)? Share your experience with other people!
Explore Other Cuisines Near Newton, New Jersey 07860
Top rated nearby
Address: 538 NJ-94 South, Fredon Township, NJ 07860, USA
Address: 269 Newton Sparta Rd, Newton, NJ 07860, USA
Address: 55 NJ-15, Lafayette, NJ 07848, USA
Address: 10 E Clinton St, Newton, NJ 07860, USA
Address: 184 Main St, Andover, NJ 07821, USA
Address: 10 E Clinton St, Newton, NJ 07860, USA
Address: 448 US-206, Newton, NJ 07860, USA
Address: 227 Newton Sparta Rd #1, Newton, NJ 07860, USA
Address: 240 Spring St, Newton, NJ 07860, USA
Address: 66 Sparta Ave, Newton, NJ 07860, USA