Geno's Steakhouse
Steak House
$$
4.6
(560)
Geno's Steakhouse offers a delightful dining experience, known for its authentic Midwestern supper club vibe and fresh ingredients. Many customers praise the quality of the steaks and seafood, alongside a well-stocked salad bar. However, some have noted inconsistencies in service, particularly during busy hours, which may affect overall satisfaction.
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (920) 525-4029
Address: N8755 Old Hwy 47, Black Creek, WI 54106, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" I came here with high hopes, but my experience was quite average. The steak I ordered was well done when I specifically asked for medium; it was still tasty, though tough. The salad bar was a bit underwhelming, lacking variety, which was disappointing given the great reviews I've heard. Service was friendly, but we had to wait a long time for our checks. I might give them another chance due to the good reputation, but I expected better on my first visit. " (*Curated Review*)
" The last-minute decision to try Geno's turned out to be one of my best! A perfect place for dinner after a long day. The decor gave me a nostalgic vibe, which was lovely. The salad bar was packed with fresh options, which made it hard to choose what to fill my plate with. I had the ribeye, and it was cooked beautifully! The only drawback was slightly longer wait times, but I felt it was worth it. Definitely on my list for future visits! " (*Curated Review*)
" Geno's has really good steak, no doubt about that! The service, however, seemed to be a bit chaotic during our visit. It took longer than expected between the courses, which dampened the experience a bit. Nonetheless, when the food arrived, it was delicious and worth the wait. The atmosphere was laid-back but could feel a little cramped when busy. I would consider giving it another shot, especially for the food! " (*Curated Review*)
" We decided to check out Geno's after hearing a lot of local buzz. The steaks (we ordered two different cuts) were cooked perfectly, yet I found the lobster tails that accompanied my meal were slightly overcooked. On the other hand, the salad bar was impressive, with a variety of toppings. Our server was sweet, but she seemed overwhelmed by the number of tables. It was quite busy that night. Overall a good experience, but there’s room for improvement mainly on seafood preparation. " (*Curated Review*)
" I was very excited to try Geno's, but I came away somewhat disappointed. The steak was medium when I ordered it rare, and the salad bar didn’t have much that stood out. The staff, while friendly, seemed overwhelmed, which detracted from the dining experience. It could be a lovely place, but I wouldn’t want to risk another disappointing visit. I might give it another shot in the future. " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (450)
" Geno's wasn't bad, but it didn't meet the expectation set by others' reviews. While my steak was decent, it lacked that special flavor I've had at other places. The atmosphere was inviting, but the service could have been better organized. I felt a little neglected due to the busy nature of the restaurant. I would consider giving it another chance at a less busy time. " (*Curated Review*)
" An outstanding place for dinner! The steak was superb—tender and flavorful. We also enjoyed the variety on the salad bar, which was fresh and well-stocked. The service was friendly but a tad slow during peak hours; however, they were attentive and responsive. The ambiance was typically warm and inviting, just what one would expect from a supper club. Can't wait to return! " (*Curated Review*)