Poppa Mia's Italian Ice House
Ice Cream Shop
4.7
(88)
Poppa Mia's Italian Ice House is celebrated for its selection of nostalgic and flavorful Italian ices. Many customers appreciate the quality and taste, noting the fun and variety of flavors available. While concerns about the artificial nature of some flavors have been raised, the overall experience remains delightful for those seeking a refreshing treat during warm weather.
Address: 469 Main St, West Sayville, NY 11796, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" Poppa Mia’s is a classic desired by locals for good reason! I love that I can keep coming back year after year and the quality remains the same. My go-to flavors are lemon and chocolate—they are amazing! I started bringing my children here, and they have fallen in love with the iced treats just like I did when I was their age. The nostalgia hits strong every time! I do wish they would expand to offer more seating options as it gets packed during peak times. However, overall, I can’t recommend this place enough! " (*Curated Review*)
" I visited Poppa Mia's last weekend to beat the heat, and I'm glad I did! The Italian ice was not only refreshing but also tasty. I loved the mango flavor, it was intense and sweet. The only downside was that it melted pretty fast! I didn’t mind though; it gave me an excuse to enjoy another scoop. The staff was friendly and kept a smile on their face despite the busy crowd. I think I’ll be back soon, especially with this summer heat! " (*Curated Review*)
" I went to Poppa Mia's after a lovely day at the beach. The ice was just what I needed! I tried the tangerine; it was vibrant and full of flavor. Although the portion sizes could be bigger, the flavor compensates! The staff was very attentive and made sure I enjoyed my treat. This is definitely a favorite cool-down spot after enjoying the sun. " (*Curated Review*)
" I had mixed feelings about my recent visit to Poppa Mia's. On one hand, the flavors of the ices are vibrant and certainly tasty; however, I noticed they might rely on artificial flavoring a bit too much. The banana flavor was bold and sweet, but it had a distinct artificial taste that was noticeable. Service was good, friendly, and relatively fast. I appreciated their variety, but I would have preferred more natural options. The atmosphere is cute, but very minimalist. It’s a great place for a quick treat rather than a place to relax. Overall, it’s nice, but I hope they consider some changes in flavoring in the future. " (*Curated Review*)
" What can I say? Poppa Mia's is a local gem! The tastes and flavors are fantastic. I can't get enough of their cherry vanilla, and my kids adore the fun, bright colors of their ices. The staff is friendly and upbeat, which adds to the overall experience. My only complaint is that they could use a bit more indoor seating during peak times, which sometimes makes it hard for families like ours to find a comfortable place to enjoy our treats. But that won’t stop us from returning for our favorite icy snack! Highly recommended! " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (72)
" While Poppa Mia’s is well-loved and has a vast array of flavors, I was a bit let down by my visit. The ice lacked the freshness I was hoping for, and the flavoring seemed overly artificial. Nevertheless, the staff was friendly and the vibe was wonderful. I would appreciate more natural options in their lineup. Although my experience wasn’t perfect, it has potential with a few adjustments. " (*Curated Review*)
" My experience at Poppa Mia’s was delightful! They have a fantastic selection of Italian ices that are both flavorful and fun! The pistachio flavor was a pleasant surprise—not too sweet and very creamy. It's the perfect treat to beat the heat, and the casual atmosphere makes it a great spot to relax and enjoy your ices. Recommend it for anyone visiting the area during the summer! " (*Curated Review*)
Have been to Poppa Mia's Italian Ice House? Share your experience with other people!
Explore Other Cuisines Near West Sayville, New York 11796
Top rated nearby
Address: 825 Montauk Hwy, Bayport, NY 11705, USA
Address: 183 N Main St, Sayville, NY 11782, USA
Address: 871 Connetquot Ave, Islip Terrace, NY 11752, USA
Address: 1274 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY 11769, USA
Address: 400 Furrows Rd, Holbrook, NY 11741, USA
Address: 507 W Main St, Patchogue, NY 11772, USA
Address: 1079 Main St, Holbrook, NY 11741, USA
Address: 1066 Main St, Holbrook, NY 11741, USA
Address: 597 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY 11769, USA
Address: 1543 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY 11769, USA