Cottage Inn Pizza Mt. Pleasant
Delivery Restaurant
$
3.6
(354)
Cottage Inn Pizza Mt. Pleasant offers a variety of pizzas and subs, with varying levels of authentic flavor. Some customers have praised the freshness and taste, while others noted inconsistencies, particularly in service and food preparation. Overall, it appears to have decent authenticity, though some dissatisfaction regarding quality has been evident.
Open until 4:00 AM
Hours from Google · may not reflect holidays or recent changes
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (989) 772-5700
Address: 1639 E Broomfield St, Mt Pleasant, MI 48858, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" I wanted to give this place a shot after hearing many good things about it, but my experience was very disappointing. I ordered online, and when I picked up my pizza it was completely cold. I had to reheat it at home, which definitely affected the taste. Luckily, the crust still retained some semblance of freshness. The staff seemed rushed as they couldn't pay attention to details. I might be willing to try a different location in the future, as I'm hopeful this was just a bad day for them. " (*Curated Review*)
" My partner and I ventured into Cottage Inn for a dinner date after hearing some recommendations. Our experience was mostly pleasant, but not without hiccups. The garlic cheese bread we ordered as an appetizer was delightful, but my pepperoni pizza came out a bit undercooked. The staff was apologetic and offered to make me a new one, which came out perfect! The ambiance was cozy, perfect for a date night, and I appreciated their attentiveness. I think I'll give them another shot, as they emphasize customer satisfaction. " (*Curated Review*)
" I ordered a variety of items for a small get-together with family and everyone seemed to enjoy it! The garlic knots were a standout; soft, buttery, and packed with flavor. My personal favorite was the BBQ chicken pizza. The flavors melded really nicely, and the portion sizes were quite generous. Everything was delivered promptly. My only complaint would be the pricing, as it felt slightly high compared to the competition. Nevertheless, I will definitely return. " (*Curated Review*)
" Let me start with the positives: their wings are incredible! I could eat them every day. The garlic butter sauce they use really made my day. On the downside, I ordered a pizza to go and found it to be slightly burnt upon receiving it. This inconsistency was disappointing because I genuinely enjoy the food. The delivery staff were friendly and made sure to check in with any needs. Overall, I have mixed feelings but the one-hit wonders keep bringing me back. " (*Curated Review*)
" Ordered the family meal deal, but it was a hassle. After calling to confirm my order, I was told I had to order online despite that not being indicated on the coupon. It was frustrating because I wanted to order the exact deal but was met with resistance. Once I finally placed my order, they didn't include everything as expected. The food itself was decent, but the service experience was far from enjoyable. I may look elsewhere next time. " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (285)
" Cottage Inn Pizza is a place with potential, yet it seems to fall short often. I ordered the deep-dish pizza, hoping for a rich, savory experience. The pizza was decent but not memorable. Another issue was the service; my order took way longer than promised, which was frustrating. The staff seemed nice, but I think they could benefit from better organization. Overall, it’s an average experience; I wouldn’t recommend it to anyone looking for a consistent pizza outing. " (*Curated Review*)
" I must say, my experience was surprisingly positive! I ordered a calzone filled with chicken, spinach, and plenty of cheese. It arrived hot and fresh, and the flavors were excellent. The staff was friendly and efficient, which is unusual after what I've heard about this place. My only complaint was the price seemed a bit high for a calzone, but the portion was generous, and I was satisfied overall. All in all, if you’re in the mood for a comforting Italian meal, I recommend this spot! " (*Curated Review*)
Have been to Cottage Inn Pizza Mt. Pleasant? Share your experience with other people!
Explore Other Cuisines Near Mount Pleasant, Michigan 48858
Top rated nearby
Address: 2320 S Mission St, Mt Pleasant, MI 48858, USA
Address: 4194 E Blue Grass Rd, Mt Pleasant, MI 48858, USA
Address: 214 N Franklin St, Mt Pleasant, MI 48858, USA
Address: 4070 E Blue Grass Rd, Mt Pleasant, MI 48858, USA
Address: 4585 E Pickard St, Mt Pleasant, MI 48858, USA
Address: 1025 S Mission St, Mt Pleasant, MI 48858, USA
Address: 1023 E Pickard St, Mt Pleasant, MI 48858, USA
Address: 1620 S Mission St Suite K, Mt Pleasant, MI 48858, USA
Address: 4445 E Blue Grass Rd, Mt Pleasant, MI 48858, USA
Address: 110 N Main St, Mt Pleasant, MI 48858, USA