484 New York Pizza
Pizza Restaurant
$
4.3
(499)
484 New York Pizza offers a diverse menu that appeals to those seeking authentic New York-style pizza in Ocala. While many customers praise the quality and taste of the pizza, some express disappointment over service consistency and certain menu items that lacked flavor or authenticity. The ambiance is generally described as cozy and welcoming.
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (352) 347-4484
Address: 1665 SW Hwy 484 #102, Ocala, FL 34473, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" We had a great dinner at 484 New York Pizza last night. Started with garlic bread which was crispy and cheesy; perfect for sharing. Then we ordered two large pizzas: one pepperoni and one veggie. While the pepperoni pizza was fantastic, the veggie pizza left much to be desired with hardly any toppings. The environment was casual and very family-friendly. It’s a pleasant place overall, albeit a little too dark for me! " (*Curated Review*)
" Visited with a large group and we had multiple items on the menu. The pizza was decent, but the garlic knots were exceptional. Some of my friends complained about their pizzas being oily and undercooked, which was upsetting because the place had high expectations based on the reviews. My slice was great, but I think consistency is key for any restaurant, especially with a reputation to uphold. " (*Curated Review*)
" I returned to 484 after hearing about their new menu. I appreciate the small updates they made to the pizza recipes. The cheese was fresh, and I loved how light and fluffy the crust was. I opted for a pepperoni. It had great flavor, but honestly, I felt that some parts were a little overcooked. Besides that, it remains my go-to spot for a quick pizza fix! " (*Curated Review*)
" Decided to try 484 for the first time and I'm glad I did! I was feeling adventurous and tried their white pizza with ricotta. My goodness, it was amazing! So creamy, the cheeses melted in my mouth, and the crust was perfection. I paired it with a refreshing salad, which only added to the experience. Overall, it was a delightful dinner for me and I’ll definitely come back for more! " (*Curated Review*)
" I had high hopes for 484 New York Pizza, especially given its name and reputation for having authentic New York-style pizza. The atmosphere was casual, and the staff were polite. I ordered a large sausage pizza and took it home. Unfortunately, while the crust was nicely crispy, the sausage was a bit bland for my taste. It's really close to what you'd expect in a NY pizzeria, but it didn't quite hit the mark for me. I might give it another try with different toppings next time. " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (401)
" When I think of New York pizza, I think of thin and crispy crust, with flavor-packed toppings. My experience at 484 New York Pizza was mostly what I expected. The slices I ordered were baked with care, and the quality of the cheese was top-notch. However, my friends had mixed experiences as they ordered different types of pizzas, which were underwhelming. I’d recommend sticking to the classic offerings where they truly excel! " (*Curated Review*)
" I ordered delivery for the first time from here and it was a bit hit or miss. On one hand, the pizza arrived hot and fresh, but the toppings were sparse. I expected to have a little more sausage on my pizza. The staff over the phone were friendly and helpful, but I wish they had better delivery options as it took longer than promised. Nevertheless, I did enjoy the flavor of the pizza, but I think I’d prefer to try next time! " (*Curated Review*)
Have been to 484 New York Pizza? Share your experience with other people!
Explore Other Cuisines Near Ocala, Florida 34473
Top rated nearby
Address: 10345 SE, US-441, Belleview, FL 34420, USA
Address: 10465 US-441, Belleview, FL 34420, USA
Address: 6106 SW State Rd 200, Ocala, FL 34476, USA
Address: 9570 SW 62nd Ave Ste 900, Ocala, FL 34476, USA
Address: 6160 SW State Rd 200 #103, Ocala, FL 34476, USA
Address: 9020 SW 27th Ave Suite B, Ocala, FL 34476, USA
Address: 2105 County Hwy 484, Ocala, FL 34473, USA
Address: 10401 US-441, Belleview, FL 34420, USA
Address: 10093 US-441, Belleview, FL 34420, USA
Address: 2655 SW Hwy 484, Ocala, FL 34473, USA