Lib's Supper Club
Italian Restaurant
$$
4.6
(838)
Lib's Supper Club is known for its generous portions and a varied menu that showcases a blend of Italian and American cuisine. Guests frequently highlight the authentic flavors of the steak and seafood dishes, and many consider it a must-visit dining spot in Elmira. The service receives praise for attentiveness, though there are occasional remarks about the atmosphere being somewhat dark. Overall, Lib's delivers an enjoyable dining experience worthy of return visits.
Closed · opens tomorrow 4:00 PM
Hours from Google · may not reflect holidays or recent changes
Restaurant website: Website
Phone number: (607) 733-2752
Address: 106 W 5th St, Elmira, NY 14901, USA
Opening hours
Photo gallery
Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)
**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**
" Lib's Supper Club has a great reputation, but I believe mine was an off-night experience. The food was just okay, not the level of excellence I've heard about. The service, however, was attentive. The calamari was soggy and the menu lacked vibrant options outside the usual fare. I opted for the steak and it was decent but again, didn’t blow me away. Perhaps a fluke, but I might choose to try something else next time. " (*Curated Review*)
" Wow! Lib's Supper Club lived up to the hype. The ambiance was incredible, and we had such a great time celebrating my parent's anniversary there. The staff were so friendly, and our server was quick to ensure we had everything we needed. The Pork Chop special was amazing with an incredible side salad. The lighting could be a bit dark if you like to read the menu without squinting, but other than that, we really enjoyed our meal! We left with leftovers for sure. We'll be back soon. " (*Curated Review*)
" I didn't know what to expect when visiting Lib's and I'm happy to say it exceeded my expectations! The interior ambiance is lovely, and the service was exceptional. The steak I ordered was juicy and cooked exactly how I wanted it. My partner got the pasta special that evening and raved about it. I enjoyed their homemade dessert, which perfectly capped off the meal. I would definitely return to try more dishes! " (*Curated Review*)
" Last night’s visit to Lib's was memorable. The house salad with their amazing Italian dressing kicked off our meal perfectly. We opted for the 16oz Filet, which was cooked exactly as requested. I appreciate the depth of flavor in their marinara sauce, which made my pasta side absolutely delicious! While the service was top-notch, the atmosphere could use a little refreshing decor-wise. However, the food more than made up for it. " (*Curated Review*)
" Lib's Supper Club is a real gem in Elmira! The staff were friendly and accommodating, making us feel welcome right away. We started with calamari, which was alright but not the highlight. However, the main dishes were fantastic. I got the Chicken Scampi and my partner had the Filet, which was cooked to perfection. I couldn't believe the portion sizes! We were so full! The atmosphere is a bit on the dark side, but it gives that cozy Italian feel. Overall, highly recommended! " (*Curated Review*)
Archived Reviews (672)
" Lib's Supper Club was a bit of a letdown this time. The steaks we ordered were overcooked and lacked seasoning, which was surprising based on previous visits. The service was good; our waitress was attentive and kind, but I expected more from the food. The atmosphere was great as usual—nice décor—but after that lack of quality in our meals, I'm not sure when I'll be back. " (*Curated Review*)
" For the price you pay, the food should be amazing, right? That's what I expected at Lib's. Unfortunately, I found my steak was just average and did not meet the hype I've heard. I had ordered a medium rare steak and it came out well done. The atmosphere was nice but overall, I felt let down by the food. Service was still excellent and attentive, but I don't think I would return soon. " (*Curated Review*)
Have been to Lib's Supper Club? Share your experience with other people!
Explore Other Cuisines Near Elmira, New York 14901
Top rated nearby
Address: 200 W Water St, Elmira, NY 14901, USA
Address: 70 Old Ithaca Rd, Horseheads, NY 14845, USA
Address: 3288 Chambers Rd, Horseheads, NY 14845, USA
Address: 102 S Main St, Horseheads, NY 14845, USA
Address: 1020 S Center St, Horseheads, NY 14845, USA
Address: 303 N Main St, Elmira, NY 14901, USA
Address: 830 County Rd 64 #16a, Elmira, NY 14903, USA
Address: 1157 N Main St #1446, Elmira, NY 14901, USA
Address: 912 Chemung St, Horseheads, NY 14845, USA
Address: 400 W Washington Ave, Elmira, NY 14901, USA