Mario's Pizzeria of Oyster Bay

Pizza Restaurant 4.5 (611)

Mario's Pizzeria is celebrated for its authentic New York-style pizza and extensive menu. Many customers delight in the genuine taste that reflects traditional Italian flavors, although service experiences can vary, affecting the overall dining experience.

Overall:

4.5

(500 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.4

Atmosphere:

4.1

Service:

4.1

Restaurant website: Website

Phone number: (516) 922-9111

Address: 253 Pine Hollow Rd, Oyster Bay, NY 11771, USA

Opening hours

Monday: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Tuesday: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Wednesday: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Thursday: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Friday: 10:00 AM – 10:30 PM
Saturday: 10:00 AM – 10:30 PM
Sunday: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Photo gallery

Service options

  • Dine-In Available
  • Takeout Available
  • Delivery Available
  • Reservable

Offerings

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Beer
  • Wine
  • Dessert
  • Vegetarian Options Available

Amenities

  • Restroom Available

Good for

  • Menu for Children
  • Good for Children
  • Good for Groups

Payment options

  • Credit Cards
  • Debit Cards
  • NFC Payments

Parking options

  • Free Parking Lot
  • Free Street Parking

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair Accessible Parking
  • Wheelchair Accessible Entrance
  • Wheelchair Accessible Restroom
  • Wheelchair Accessible Seating

Top Recent and Curated Reviews (10)

**Some reviews are curated to assist in analyzing authenticity, atmosphere, and service. These reviews enhance user feedback and help us provide better insights. Your genuine reviews make all the difference—share your experience today to enhance our ratings!**

" Mario's Pizzeria is a slice of heaven! The classic Margarita pizza is outstanding, you really can taste the quality in the fresh ingredients. The service was prompt, and I loved the lively vibe of the place, making it perfect for families or a casual night out. " (*Curated Review*)

8 months ago

" Had a fun night out with friends at Mario's! We shared a big pizza and the flavors were incredible! The atmosphere was buzzing with energy, and the staff were friendly and attentive. Can't wait to have another feast here soon! " (*Curated Review*)

8 months ago

" Last week, my friends and I visited Mario's for dinner. The pizza was above average, but I found the service slower than expected. The atmosphere was nice, with a lively crowd, but I left feeling a bit let down. I'll give it another try, hoping for a better experience. " (*Curated Review*)

9 months ago

" Every time I visit Mario's I get the same comforting feeling. The pizza is always consistent and delicious. Their Sicilian slice is my go-to, thick and flavorful. The service is quick, even when busy, and the atmosphere is great, making it the perfect spot for a casual night out. " (*Curated Review*)

11 months ago

" Caught wind of Mario's on social media and couldn't resist trying it out. The pizza has that authentic New York flavor - absolutely fantastic! I had their buffalo chicken slice and it was spicy and flavorful. The restaurant has a great vibe, and staff were super engaging. Highly impressed! " (*Curated Review*)

11 months ago

Archived Reviews (490)

" Had dinner at Mario's and left impressed! The pizza was packed with flavor, and I loved their unique options beyond the standard selections. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, definitely making it a family-friendly spot. Highly recommend trying their specialty slices! " (*Curated Review*)

1 year ago

" So my friends recommended Mario's for great pizza, and they did not steer me wrong! I was blown away by their vegetable pizza - it was so fresh and flavorful, definitely worth every bite. The service was fantastic, and the place was bustling without feeling overcrowded. Will definitely be back soon! " (*Curated Review*)

1 year ago
More reviews not shown...

Have been to Mario's Pizzeria of Oyster Bay? Share your experience with other people!

Please enter at least 15 characters.
no selection

Explore Other Cuisines Near Oyster Bay, New York 11771

Top rated nearby

Phil's Pizzeria & Restaurant Syosset
Pizza Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.8

(884 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.8

Atmosphere:

4.7

Service:

4.9

Address: 265 Jericho Turnpike, Syosset, NY 11791, USA
Samovar Restaurant
Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.6

(128 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.8

Atmosphere:

4.6

Service:

4.5

Address: 27 Woodbury Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
Rare650 Prime Steak and Sushi
Steak House $$$$

Overall:

4.7

(1096 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.4

Atmosphere:

4.7

Service:

4.6

Address: 650 Jericho Turnpike, Syosset, NY 11791, USA
Mahal
Indian Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.8

(244 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.6

Atmosphere:

4.6

Service:

4.7

Address: 290 Glen Cove Rd, Roslyn Heights, NY 11577, USA
Mithaas Hicksville
Indian Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.5

(1429 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.5

Atmosphere:

4.1

Service:

4.2

Address: 217 Bethpage Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
DD Hibachi & Soup Dumpling - best; best restaurant long island; best dumpling long island; best hibachi; hibachi near me;
Restaurant $$

Overall:

5.0

(802 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.8

Atmosphere:

5.0

Service:

5.0

Address: 111 Jericho Turnpike, Jericho, NY 11753, USA
Gyrolicious
Mediterranean Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.8

(272 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.6

Atmosphere:

4.5

Service:

4.7

Address: 24a Jericho Turnpike, Jericho, NY 11753, USA
Chris & Tony’s
Italian Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.8

(578 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.6

Atmosphere:

4.5

Service:

4.8

Address: 352 Jericho Turnpike, Syosset, NY 11791, USA
Stellina Ristorante
Italian Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.7

(95 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.7

Atmosphere:

4.6

Service:

4.5

Address: 76 South St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771, USA
Season Glen Head
Restaurant $$

Overall:

4.8

(72 reviews)

Authenticity:

4.7

Atmosphere:

4.6

Service:

4.5

Address: 133 Glen Head Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545, USA